How pitted is too pitted?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

2airishuman

Contributor
Messages
2,682
Reaction score
2,007
Location
Greater Minnesota
# of dives
200 - 499
Some findings on craigslist this week, two sets of hot dip galvanized HP120 banded doubles, and an HP40 stage. Those I had to pay real money for. They need hydro but I don't anticipate any problems.

Also two 1960s era tanks, an LP72 and an oddball U.S. Divers cylinder rated 3AA-1800, that's 1980 with the +, works out to 52 cf. I paid very little for those because the seller knew they had some internal corrosion and disclosed that. He said a former owner used his own compressor with questionable filtration. Tanks and valves were a mess with soot-like material as well as some rust dust. I disassembled, cleaned, rinsed, dried.

Looking inside the tanks, there is some corrosion and pitting. I'd like to try to save the LP72, and there's a local hydro facility that performs internal shot blasting, which they say is a better choice than tumbling. The 52 cf I'm thinking is probably best used as a wind chime, but who knows. The pitting is worse on that one and it has the brown internal coating.

Is there any way I can evaluate the pitting on the 72 and get a better idea whether the tank can be salvaged? Hate to waste time and money taking it to the hydro shop if it's a lost cause.
 
After bead blasting and hydro you will have spent how much for the tank. Where I live nobody will fill the tank regardless of hydro and how pretty the inside looks. Plus there is a good chance that the shop that will fill it will only go to 2300/psi. Giving you like 65 cuft......make sure the end product has utility.
 
Policy. You don't like it. Go elsewhere. I had the hydro 5 aluminum tanks and then 2 months later after oxygen cleaning them too. They say they are too old to fill. Sorry..
 
Policy. You don't like it. Go elsewhere. I had the hydro 5 aluminum tanks and then 2 months later after oxygen cleaning them too. They say they are too old to fill. Sorry..

Are you saying that the tanks passed the hydros, then you paid them for O2 cleaning, and THEN they told you they were just too old to fill/sorry?
 
After bead blasting and hydro you will have spent how much for the tank. Where I live nobody will fill the tank regardless of hydro and how pretty the inside looks. Plus there is a good chance that the shop that will fill it will only go to 2300/psi. Giving you like 65 cuft......make sure the end product has utility.

Shot blasting $15.38
Hydro $19.48
VIP $1 if done at the same time as hydro

No one's making galvanized tanks any more. I can get a new painted LP85 for $279. Seems like I'm in the money so far.

Nobody will fill an older steel tank that's in hydro and viz? What year is the cutoff? Somebody tell me again why I'm supposed to support my LDS.
 
Are you saying that the tanks passed the hydros, then you paid them for O2 cleaning, and THEN they told you they were just too old to fill/sorry?
yup....I think they said I should have asked (if they were gonna change their policy in the immediate future)..
 
Those are good prices... but you need to ask about the final outcome..Those are great tanks for women and children.. What are you gonna do with it?
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom