I'm finally taking this trip in July! Hoping to hit Tioman, Tenggol, and Redang after an epic month in Indonesia (North Sulawesi, Nusa Penida, and Komodo).
1. How many days should I spend diving each?
2. Should I stay in Dungun or Tenggol to dive Tenggol?
and to piggyback on this...
3. How about Manado or Bunaken for two days of diving?
1.
As a Malaysian, I always target to stay 4d3n or 5d4n (with 10 - 12 dives) before I missed my city life but this is knowing i can always visit it again.
Tioman - It has multiple village (Kampung) with jetty and no road connecting each other, so where you stay will determine which area / dive site you will go. Most of the dive sites is located at north west of island where Labas dive site is my favorite. 1 village located at east of island and it is mostly for macro stuff.
Tenggol - Done 10 dives there, healthy coral but disappointed with the amount of fishes. Famous for whale shark sighting but no luck for me, I even ended up diving at same site twice just to hope to have a glimpse on whale shark.
Redang - Only done 4 dives but nothing impress me.
2.
I will recommend to stay in Tenggol if you can afford it based on following points:-
You get to freshen up after every dives at resort if staying in the island, where you are stuck on island whole day if staying in Dungun and dive at Tenggol (which is 1hr boat ride 1 way)
Only 1 small beach with 3 small resorts, limited phone coverage. It is very peaceful and quiet at night except at the main dining area where guests tend to mingle and drink together. Water is much cleaner on the island compared to the water at dock at Dungun.
Coral Beach Resort has fantastic food and teabreak (inclusive in package), food in Dungun may be limited in terms of cooking style (Malay food)