Make sure they are snug on your hands. The looser they are, the more water can enter, the colder your hands. It's a fine balance between snug and too tight. Try on a few, remember they will stretch a tiny bit with age.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
I've been very happy with my XS Scuba Drive-5 gloves XS Scuba 5mm Dry Five Pyrostretch Dry Gloves
I have a pair of these and find them no warmer than my AquaLung 5mm kevlar gloves - and they are much more of a pain on and off. I go with 7mm 3 finger mitts when I need more.I've been very happy with my XS Scuba Drive-5 gloves XS Scuba 5mm Dry Five Pyrostretch Dry Gloves
Technically these are semi-dry gloves. I have no trouble manipulating my camera with them and have much better dexterity that the Atlas/Showa 'papa smurf' gloves I was using before.
Local diving means the water can be in the low 40's. YMMV
Icechip, I used to dive with "three finger" gloves made from 1/4" neoprene. They look like what they sound like. Two of your fingers go into each "finger" on the glove, so you've got some dexterity but in theory the two fingers together help conserve some heat. I'm not sure if anyone makes those anymore.