Hundreds of dives. Never, ever a mid-dive failure.
I have had three times where I closed the fluffy yellow inner glove in the ring. I ditched those, and it hasn't happened since.
I've punctured two mid-dive - so not a failure. More seepage.
Dry Gloves rule.
I was diving with someone this weekend. She had a custom DUI suit, top-of-the line DUI undies, etc. Her rig it top notch - BP/W, etc. She makes an excellent living, she's smart, funny, engaged... and she dives wet hands.
I was poking her about it. Telling her to embrace the technology. I demanded when she get home she get a push button phone, and get dry gloves.