Diver dies at Monastery Beach

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Here's the text of the story:

Diver dies in tall waves off Monastery Beach
Carmel: Two others escape from ocean surge
By LAITH AGHA
Herald Staff Writer
Article Last Updated: 12/29/2007 01:30:07 AM PST

Two dive partners who were involved in a struggle of their own with Monastery Beach's notoriously dangerous undertow reportedly did not see what chain of events led to Edward Diaz of Las Vegas being found floating face down and unconscious in the water.

Nearly 90 minutes after Diaz was pulled from the water, he was pronounced dead at Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula. He was 39.

Diaz, described as a master diver who used to live in the Monterey area, worked at Colorado River Divers dive shop in Las Vegas, said Jay Gundy, the store's owner. Gundy declined to comment further.

The cause of death has not been determined, said State Parks spokesman Mike McMenamy.

The ocean conditions at Monastery Beach, about a mile south of the Carmel River Lagoon, were "super dangerous," said State Parks lifeguard Erik Larson.

The ocean swell was more than 11 feet around the time of the incident, said Steve Anderson, meteorologist at the National Weather Service's Monterey office.

"It's a dangerous beach to start with," Larson said. "Entry and exit is difficult, then add all the equipment, that makes it even more difficult."

Neither of Diaz's dive partners would talk to news reporters. Larson relayed their account of the incident.

As they were entering the water around 11:30 a.m., fully outfitted in their diving gear, one of the surviving divers was overtaken by a surge while standing knee-deep in the water. The other surviving diver took off his
Advertisement
equipment to maximize his mobility as he attempted to rescue his distressed partner. He managed to get him out of the water after several arduous minutes.

When the two looked for Diaz, they spotted him floating in the water face down.

"They were so exhausted from the first rescue, they couldn't get to him at first," Larson said.

They eventually managed to get him out of the water, at which point a sheriff's deputy had arrived. Paramedics with the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection arrived shortly after and immediately began performing CPR on Diaz, who was not breathing, Larson said.

Paramedics continued CPR for more than 30 minutes before taking Diaz to Community Hospital. He was pronounced dead around 1 p.m., said McMenamy.

Diaz's death adds to the beach's reputation as one of the most dangerous spots along Monterey County's coast. Notoriously referred to as "Mortuary" Beach, its steep-sloping shore makes it deceptively dangerous.

"It's one of the deadliest beaches around here," said James Vincent, an employee at Aquarius Dive Shop. "You really have to pick the right days."

Vincent said he has been involved in several close calls at Monastery Beach since he began diving the area about nine months ago.

Because of Monastery's steep shore — angled at about 45 degrees — waves don't crash on it the way they do on flatter beaches. Instead, the surge of energy passing through the water hits Monastery as a shorebreak, followed by a strong backwash.

Larson emphasized the need for exercising extra caution when diving at Monastery. He said divers should spend at least 30 minutes assessing the water's conditions before entering, and once in the water, they should always be working as a team.

"This spot is for experienced divers only," Larson said. "Divers shouldn't go out unless they're in good condition and the ocean conditions are good. Make sure you're entering the ocean in a safe place."
 
Here's some pictures for some of you who have no idea what we are talking about

Monastery Beach Thread

So sorry to hear of the incident.........beautiful area, why not use a boat & get it from above vs from land???..........
 
So sorry to hear of the incident.........beautiful area, why not use a boat & get it from above vs from land???..........


Why use a boat when you can get to it from land?

Frankly if you have a boat wou wouldn't go here.. it's quite a ways away from any boat launch and there's a bunch of nice dive spots between the boat ramp and here
 
So sorry to hear of the incident.........beautiful area, why not use a boat & get it from above vs from land???..........

There is good shore diving along the Monterey coast. Make your own schedule and spend $85 less. Boats do have the advantage you point out, plus less time spent in the cold water, as most shore dives have a bit of a surface swim to take best advantage of the site.

On a day like that one, bringing a boat around from Monterey to Monastery beach would be an unpleasant ride -- swells about 3 feet above my personal seasickness level. My choice would have been to stay home, or perhaps check out one of the more protected shore diving sites along Monterey and Pacific Grove to verify that I was really ready to go back home.
 
...beautiful area, why not use a boat & get it from above vs from land???..........

Boats cost money and the closest public ramp is one of two in Monterey (maybe 10 miles each way). There is a boat ramp at Point Lobos State Park less than 2 miles away, but bigger boats (< 18 ft) aren't usually able to launch from there. And if you're launching from Point Lobos, it is generally considered a better dive site anyway.

North Monastery is sometimes dived by boat people for the pelagics. I've seen some sharks there, along with some HUGE Mola Molas. On the surface, Humpbacks and Dolphins frequent the area.

Here is a link from California Dive News:

Monterey County - Monasterey Beach - Scuba Dive Spot
 
So sorry to hear of the incident.........beautiful area, why not use a boat & get it from above vs from land???..........

Besides what others have posted, the anchorage would be a bit difficult. With the usual
NW winds, your boat will be on the beach if the anchor drags much, with most anything
else, it will drift to Siberia before the hook catches again.

And there's not much place to put the hook. It's either in the kelp bed, or too deep.

And yesterday was a Friday, and the commercial boats generally don't run on weekdays.
 
That introduces another possibility: "It's my 100th dive and by gum I'm going to do it
at Monastery.".

That is such a good point Chuck.

I am trying to be very careful how I say this as it is in no way intended to sound disrespectful.

But I also noticed the term, MASTER DIVER, Was used a lot in the articles, This does not mean we are Masters Of the sport, I am also a Master scuba diver -Instructor.

That does Not make me MR Scuba, And I still have a lot too learn.

My point...... A master diver rating and with only 99 dives is not all of that great of an experienced diver!

I think a lot is not so much the rating or the numbers but MAYBE the quality of the dive and the learning we get from each dive, I hope that makes sense as again I am trying to be very respectful of my wording!

The wording in the article I feel would tend to lead the general public to think this gentalman out to be a 5000 dives type veteran diver??:confused:
 
I just can't imagine anyone looking at that...and saying "yeah that's totally doable!!"
 
I just can't imagine anyone looking at that...and saying "yeah that's totally doable!!"

I agree so strongly!!

How COULD anyone think that a good... Or safe dive???

I would be on my way home or at least to the breakwater!

I feel so bad and sad for that man and feel a huge loss to our dive community:shakehead:
 

Back
Top Bottom