Canon G10 or G11?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Nemrod -
This information is really good as one of the primary things I'm after is a faster shutter speed. I'd be interested in how the G11 does comparatively.

JoyfulLee
 
Can anyone comment on the shutter lag of either of these cameras? I really hate watching the fish turn away as my camera is deciding to take the picture (even when prefocused).

It is really quick topside anyway. I got the G11 and Canon undwater housing for Christmas. Only 3 weeks until it gets submerged.
 
Shutter lag times from : Compare Digital Cameras - Camera Prices and Reviews

Model Name: Canon PowerShot G11 Canon PowerShot S90
Startup Time: 2.5 seconds 2.1 seconds
Shutdown Time: 1.5 seconds 1.5 seconds
Play -> Record: 1.7 seconds 1.3 seconds
Record -> Play (max res): 2.5 seconds 2.5 seconds
Record -> Play (min res):
Shutter Lag, Full AF: 0.540 (W) - 0.750 (T) seconds 0.430 (W) - 0.490 (T) seconds
Shutter Lag, Man. Focus: 0.470 seconds 0.410 seconds
Shutter Lag, Prefocus: 0.072 seconds 0.088 seconds
Cycle Time Uncompressed Format: 2.80 seconds 2.96 seconds
Cycle Time Max Res: 2.29 seconds 2.43 seconds
Cycle Time Min Res:
Buffer Frames, Max Res: No limit No limit
Continuous Mode Rate (fps): 1.10 0.94
 
A couple more comments on shutter lag and RAW / JPEG.....

Measuring these little cameras shutter specs is meanlingless.......Practice is more important!

Get a S90 or G11 and start shooting to learn how the AF works.....Nemrod's suggestion of possibly the Face Detect (AiAF, too) and SERVO might work well, too.

Setting focus manually to me is like getting a root canal :( I may try it with a WA lens mounted and as Nemrod stated shutter lag would be non-existent. Just need to ensure it will have enough DOF (depth of field) at any aperture.....

As far as shooting RAW and JPEG, why? Waste of file space IMHO.......If you want to do post processing and think you will gain that much more from such a small sensor just shoot RAW.

I have shot some RAW just to see how fast the S90 processes the files (which come out as 10-12MB!) and it's fine. RAW and JPEG takes too long for me.

Plus the JPEG files I'm getting look great as long as you get a decent exposure. My mantra is "shoot a lot and get it right!" versus trying to save a crappy exposure.

Still learning using my Canon S90 camera day by day......But I still MAY buy a Canon G11 (and 270EX flash) for surface shooting, too.......

UW the little Canon S90 is proving to be a great choice.

YMMV

dhaas
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0745.jpg
    IMG_0745.jpg
    32.3 KB · Views: 75
From a web site:

Autofocus: So far so good; I haven’t used so many P&Ss that I can compare AF speed, so all I can say is it’s slower than my DSLR, but faster than a tortoise, and certainly adequate for my needs. Cool feature: You can set AF to face recognition and it will try to find a face anywhere in the frame in order to focus on it; if it doesn’t find it, it focuses on something else and shows a green square (or more) around that area. I can see this feature appealing to mums and dads trying to get their kids’ faces sharp. Combine this with servo focusing (Canon-speak for continuous focus) and you can at least stand a chance against any 5-year old.

and:

Shutter lag is one of the most important properties for a P&S, because historically we’ve been given P&Ss that allow us to make coffee during the time it takes them to take the shot after pressing the shutter release. Not so with the S90, not even The Flash could get away with making coffee. There is clearly some lag when using autofocus, which is no worse than other P&Ss I have tried (not that many, to be honest) and is due to the focusing action, but when shooting in manual focus there is no perceptible lag.

In order to prove to myself that there really was no lag, I set a stopwatch running and took a photograph of it every 10s for 100s, measuring the delay between me pressing the button as the stopwatch hit 10s, 20s, 30s, and the time shown in each photo. The lag I measured is 160ms, which is in the same league as some DSLRs (high end DSLRs are in the 50ms range, while middle tier models are around 100ms). In real life, 160ms is just as good as instantaneous. Another gold star for Canon.

From:

Review – Canon S90, Part 2: Using the Camera Enticing the Light

Head to head with my 570 the S90 is faster on the shutter but when recording RAW plus JPEG slower to the next shot unless I am using the hack with the 570 an then the 570 is much slower. But then, I have decided RAW is possibly much fuss over very little with small sensor cameras.

Really, this cycle time is faster than with my Nikonos III or a housed SLR, shot to shot, unless I kept my finger on the winder lever and was prefocused (I am talking film, manual cameras) so possibly some people are spoiled, maybe.

N

Just to make sure I did not confuse people, the very last two paragraphs were my observations, the other information was quoted from the web page that I linked to. Just to make sure y'all understand. I wish I were that much of an expert but I am not :). It made sense (given what I know) so I quoted it here and then provided the link to the full article.

N
 
Interesting thread. It has been quiet a while since shutter lag has been a concern.. almost forgot anyone would even be concerned about it.

I'm seriously considering adding an S90 to use as my travel camera... yea you give up some resolution over the G10, but the small size sure would be nice
 
It is really quick topside anyway. I got the G11 and Canon undwater housing for Christmas. Only 3 weeks until it gets submerged.

Feedback on your camera during your trip???
Thx
 
This has been answered a couple dozen times, but my 2 cents are for the G11
 

Back
Top Bottom