c. As an instructor, I've made the decision that NONE of my students will do the 200 yard "
swim" because it TEACHES THEM NOTHING and tells me very little. OTOH, having them do the 300 yard, MFS "
swim" (or whatever you want to call it) as a buddy team, teaches them a lot and tells me something about their ability to be a diver.
LOL. Well said!Peter, just as I found Walter's comment (which may seem to be a bit at odds with your approach) enlightening, I am also intrigued by yours. I have not been looking at the Watermanship Skills as a teaching opportunity, rather as a safety check at the beginning of OW training, and I may be missing a chance both to facilitate student learning, and to assess student ability.
Peter, had the chance to start using the 300 yard MFS swim with a private OW class in February. I agree with your comments - it really did give me a chance to see how they a) used their fins, b) breathed through a 'device' with their face (in a mask) in the water. I found it very helpful, and will continue the practice - all students will do the 300 yard MFS swim. Thanks for your post.