Can a certified cave diver escort a non cave diver
- Thread starter Tigerpaw
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
That totally makes sense and should definitely be included in the reasons why folks cave dive....
Although NOT a cave diver, I did have an experience about 30 years ago while on a trip to Coz. We saw a flyer at a small dive op shop and group of four of us took a day to take the ferry over to Playa to do the Cenote thing. I don't even remember the name of the op or guide that took us. None of us were cave certified..... We just showed up with the same gear we would use on any normal no deco night dive. Not that it was a good idea, but I know for sure that we at least briefly transited some areas of that system where there was no surface light available. We had a great time and just followed the guide. It was absolutely beautiful and the vis seemed basically unlimited. I guess at that time it all just seemed perfectly safe and definitely seemed a LOT safer than some of the penetration, night, drysuit, low vis wreck dives we had done back home...
It retrospect, maybe that Cenote experience was reckless or stupid......but it sure didn't seem so at the time.
you don't have to have overhead light for it to be a cenote dive. just a visible source of light. I love cenote dives but damn if Tulum hasn't gotten all bougie and expensive. I think now they are charging like $200 for a two tank dive.
For my NACD/NSS-CDS Cavern course in 1988 (pre-www), I showed up with the open water gear I was using for diving MO freshwater lakes. (MO groundwater temps are in the low-to-mid-50 degee F range.) We were all told to each additionally bring only a complete second regulator, a second U/W flashlight, and a second dive knife (IIRC). Because I was continuing for the Basic Cave training immediately afterward, my second U/W flashlight needed to be a bit more capable than the Mini-C's I usually carried. I took an Underwater Kinetics model with a lantern grip (?) as my primary light.
The Cavern course opened with discussions pertaining to why the usual open water gear was NOT safe, as is, for diving in cavern and cave environments, and our open water gear was reconfigured to be safer for this.
IIRC, the only additional gear I needed to purchase after I arrived at Ginnie Springs FL for those courses, were a 5-ft regulator hose, a cave reel, a backup reel, cave line, a couple of line arrows, and some oxygen tubing (for doing things like fashioning a necklace, etc.). Duct tape I already had in my car trunk.
So, I did the two courses, over four long days, using what was essentially open-water gear that had been transformed to be more compatible with Cavern- and Basic Cave-level diving, as described in the NSS-CDS Cavern Diving Manual.
As mentioned in my earlier post in this thread, we were told that, within strict limits, with our new training we could do mini cave dives relatively safely, to see if cave diving was something that we ultimately would want to pursue further.
This was excellent training, IMHO--an excellent approach to setting us up to relatively safely, but not prohibitively expensively, see if cave diving was something we wanted to pursue.
rx7diver
The Cavern course opened with discussions pertaining to why the usual open water gear was NOT safe, as is, for diving in cavern and cave environments, and our open water gear was reconfigured to be safer for this.
IIRC, the only additional gear I needed to purchase after I arrived at Ginnie Springs FL for those courses, were a 5-ft regulator hose, a cave reel, a backup reel, cave line, a couple of line arrows, and some oxygen tubing (for doing things like fashioning a necklace, etc.). Duct tape I already had in my car trunk.
So, I did the two courses, over four long days, using what was essentially open-water gear that had been transformed to be more compatible with Cavern- and Basic Cave-level diving, as described in the NSS-CDS Cavern Diving Manual.
As mentioned in my earlier post in this thread, we were told that, within strict limits, with our new training we could do mini cave dives relatively safely, to see if cave diving was something that we ultimately would want to pursue further.
This was excellent training, IMHO--an excellent approach to setting us up to relatively safely, but not prohibitively expensively, see if cave diving was something we wanted to pursue.
rx7diver
OP
UPDATE, I PASSED MY CAVERN OPEN WATER!!! I need to tweak my buoyancy and continue to work on it and practice tie off's, BUT that's what the local lake is for. Oh and my instructor DID take me a little bit into a cave!
Going to be offline tonight as I have my written exam tomorrow. So I'm going to be studying this evening and into the night. Currently doing laundry as I fly back tomorrow evening! Halfway there!!!!!!!
Once I pass the written exam ( said with confidence, NOT cockiness) I start a thread detailing my experience.
Going to be offline tonight as I have my written exam tomorrow. So I'm going to be studying this evening and into the night. Currently doing laundry as I fly back tomorrow evening! Halfway there!!!!!!!
Once I pass the written exam ( said with confidence, NOT cockiness) I start a thread detailing my experience.
A long long answer will follow 
and some maybe not completely on topic.
I think it depends on where you live. In my country, there is no law for diving, so everybody can go diving without a cert and, you are insuranced on the national health insurance. But we don't have caves in my country. But things as 'you are diving outside a certification limit' does not make any sense in my country. Yes, the pointing fingers are there, but as instructor we can only advice people to take courses, but we cannot do anything against people who are doing things on their own. And yes, I also did before I was instructor. I have done deep night dives as open water diver, started with decompression diver after getting my aow, took some not certified divers on a dive when I was dm, and even gave an introduction of cave diving in an old slate mine in Belgium. This was all before I became instructor. And nothing was against the law, you could not get a fine. Maybe if something went wrong there was something that could give a discussion, but I know from others that the problems are bigger if you do something wrong as instructor than that you are no instructor and teach the same things. But you also can found your own agency in my country. I know from some divers who did it and bombed themselves to instructor for everything. I decided after 3 years to follow the normal path to become instructor and did it with an (w)rstc agency and then did a crossover also to cmas because I am member of a cmas club, but don't teach cmas a lot.
In France, caves are free to enter. So people get in without a cave cert (and also 1 of the rescueers of the thai cave rescue did not have a cave cert).
Now I would not advice to take someone in a cave if you are not an cave instructor. It has nothing to do with that I want to earn money, but I have rescued 2 times people from a cave (both times alive as they found an airbell). In 1 time it were no cave divers, but a group of people who did their sundaymorningdive and did not use lines. In the other case it were certified cavedivers and after analyzing, nobody did anything wrong, but only some bad luck in zero viz (and an example that bump and go is less safe than touch contact).
But yes, I have some problems with some certs in diving that are made 'mandatory' by some people. I have sometimes problems with the diving industry as with every step you must be taken by hand and there is no way for autodidactical divers. And I was one of that autodidacts with a lot of things. I always say there are usefull certs like open water, advanced nitrox, a cave diving course. There are courses just for fun like biology, most times photography specialties, etc. And there are courses that can be useful. These are certs that are in the range 'can be good, but not for everybody needed'. For recreational diving it is for example drysuit diving, but also sidemount diving is 1 of that certs. For technical diving multiple stage cave diving is such an example. If you are a full trimix diver, you are used to more cylinders. The theory behind multiple stage is no rocket science. Also the expedition trimix diver is a course that can be usefull, but not needed. A full trimix diver has no limites anymore. My instructor trainer when I did the full trimix instructor course sometimes teaches the expedition trimix. As I have never done that course and have been to 135m and 123 in a cave (these are depths outside the expedition trimix also), we talked about what I could learn from that course. He said nothing. It is the most dangerous course to teach. People who want to dive over 100m and are capable will do it themselves. Others take a course and that are not the most capable technical divers. The expedition trimix course is not written to reach more depth, but also to think about expeditions and safety divers, etc. And people who go beyond 100m most times get the knowledge by reading, using internet, asking people, or just role in it because of they belong to a group with that experience, etc.
But about the 'can be usefull courses: If you are unsure, take a course. If you have a good buddy or camera, you can do it yourself, with sidemount all skills are shown on youtube, gas is gas. But adjusting an harness can take a long time and sometimes you don't feel things yourself. This is where an instructor or good buddy or a camera can help. And yes, self teaching results also in 'diving with sidemount equipment' instead of diving sidemount, but it is not directly dangerous. A drysuit can be dangerous, but it is no rocket science. Adding more cylinders in a cave is often done carefully by progressing carefully after a full cave course. IANTD offers stage dropping in the (technical) cave course, TDI not I believe (at least we did not do it when I did my tdi full cave course). But when you are a trimix diver, you can go as deep as your cert is after getting full cave certified.
I dove already a couple of years with ccr in a cave and I cannot say I learned from an oc to ccr cave crossover. We had a lot of fun, for sure, but a ccr cave crossover does not bring you with scooters far in a cave to depths over 75m, that is beyond every course, and that where the dives we already did. But I have sometimes people for the crossover that are not that experienced and they like it to do. First the ccr cave course was more or less optional if you had already oc cave and a ccr cert. But now it looks like it changed to mandatory. If you ask people here on Scubaboard, some will find the crossover usefull, others just something that someone wants to earn money about. The answers most times depends on the experience people already had before doing it.
For wreckdiving, the full cave card is higher than a technical wreck diver card. You can penetrate wrecks with a full cave diver card, but you cannot dive caves with a wreck diver card. Some people who only dive wrecks try to change this. But I don't see any need for myself.
The discussion to stay on intro to cave level for a while is one that will never finish. For some divers, intro to cave level will be fine, but what I see here in Europe is that most divers on that level go over their certification limits within less than 5 dives. The 1/6th rule is the first that is overtaken. Then it is the no deco and the no jump. So then I always advice to combine all cave courses together. What you see then is that people are more carefull and they have learned how to do things right. But a lot of people who take the cave diving courses in Europe are already technical divers at least on advanced nitrox level. They don't start with a single tank. I also advice people to do adv. nitrxo before doing a cave course. I never gave or will give intro to cave with a single tank.
I also don't want to see an fundies/essentials/basics of tech course as mandatory, it can be usefull for a lot of people, but not for all a needed course to progress.
I like the option to have steps between courses like from adv. nitrox the step to add some helium before going to the 60m trimix cert, but only as optional.
So conclusion about your question: if you instructor is just a cave diver and cavern instructor, he cannot bring you on a cave dive at the next level. If the instructor is at least an intro to cave instructor, he can.
If it is just a friend who wants to take you on a cave dive, I would advice not to do, but it is probably not forbidden by law.
And sometimes you get in strange situations, only single tank options, a guide that has no cave cert, but he is the only way to bring you in a cave and you are a full cave diver. Then if such a thing happens, be careful, but I know, most divers will not say no to it. But use your brains.
and some maybe not completely on topic.I think it depends on where you live. In my country, there is no law for diving, so everybody can go diving without a cert and, you are insuranced on the national health insurance. But we don't have caves in my country. But things as 'you are diving outside a certification limit' does not make any sense in my country. Yes, the pointing fingers are there, but as instructor we can only advice people to take courses, but we cannot do anything against people who are doing things on their own. And yes, I also did before I was instructor. I have done deep night dives as open water diver, started with decompression diver after getting my aow, took some not certified divers on a dive when I was dm, and even gave an introduction of cave diving in an old slate mine in Belgium. This was all before I became instructor. And nothing was against the law, you could not get a fine. Maybe if something went wrong there was something that could give a discussion, but I know from others that the problems are bigger if you do something wrong as instructor than that you are no instructor and teach the same things. But you also can found your own agency in my country. I know from some divers who did it and bombed themselves to instructor for everything. I decided after 3 years to follow the normal path to become instructor and did it with an (w)rstc agency and then did a crossover also to cmas because I am member of a cmas club, but don't teach cmas a lot.
In France, caves are free to enter. So people get in without a cave cert (and also 1 of the rescueers of the thai cave rescue did not have a cave cert).
Now I would not advice to take someone in a cave if you are not an cave instructor. It has nothing to do with that I want to earn money, but I have rescued 2 times people from a cave (both times alive as they found an airbell). In 1 time it were no cave divers, but a group of people who did their sundaymorningdive and did not use lines. In the other case it were certified cavedivers and after analyzing, nobody did anything wrong, but only some bad luck in zero viz (and an example that bump and go is less safe than touch contact).
But yes, I have some problems with some certs in diving that are made 'mandatory' by some people. I have sometimes problems with the diving industry as with every step you must be taken by hand and there is no way for autodidactical divers. And I was one of that autodidacts with a lot of things. I always say there are usefull certs like open water, advanced nitrox, a cave diving course. There are courses just for fun like biology, most times photography specialties, etc. And there are courses that can be useful. These are certs that are in the range 'can be good, but not for everybody needed'. For recreational diving it is for example drysuit diving, but also sidemount diving is 1 of that certs. For technical diving multiple stage cave diving is such an example. If you are a full trimix diver, you are used to more cylinders. The theory behind multiple stage is no rocket science. Also the expedition trimix diver is a course that can be usefull, but not needed. A full trimix diver has no limites anymore. My instructor trainer when I did the full trimix instructor course sometimes teaches the expedition trimix. As I have never done that course and have been to 135m and 123 in a cave (these are depths outside the expedition trimix also), we talked about what I could learn from that course. He said nothing. It is the most dangerous course to teach. People who want to dive over 100m and are capable will do it themselves. Others take a course and that are not the most capable technical divers. The expedition trimix course is not written to reach more depth, but also to think about expeditions and safety divers, etc. And people who go beyond 100m most times get the knowledge by reading, using internet, asking people, or just role in it because of they belong to a group with that experience, etc.
But about the 'can be usefull courses: If you are unsure, take a course. If you have a good buddy or camera, you can do it yourself, with sidemount all skills are shown on youtube, gas is gas. But adjusting an harness can take a long time and sometimes you don't feel things yourself. This is where an instructor or good buddy or a camera can help. And yes, self teaching results also in 'diving with sidemount equipment' instead of diving sidemount, but it is not directly dangerous. A drysuit can be dangerous, but it is no rocket science. Adding more cylinders in a cave is often done carefully by progressing carefully after a full cave course. IANTD offers stage dropping in the (technical) cave course, TDI not I believe (at least we did not do it when I did my tdi full cave course). But when you are a trimix diver, you can go as deep as your cert is after getting full cave certified.
I dove already a couple of years with ccr in a cave and I cannot say I learned from an oc to ccr cave crossover. We had a lot of fun, for sure, but a ccr cave crossover does not bring you with scooters far in a cave to depths over 75m, that is beyond every course, and that where the dives we already did. But I have sometimes people for the crossover that are not that experienced and they like it to do. First the ccr cave course was more or less optional if you had already oc cave and a ccr cert. But now it looks like it changed to mandatory. If you ask people here on Scubaboard, some will find the crossover usefull, others just something that someone wants to earn money about. The answers most times depends on the experience people already had before doing it.
For wreckdiving, the full cave card is higher than a technical wreck diver card. You can penetrate wrecks with a full cave diver card, but you cannot dive caves with a wreck diver card. Some people who only dive wrecks try to change this. But I don't see any need for myself.
The discussion to stay on intro to cave level for a while is one that will never finish. For some divers, intro to cave level will be fine, but what I see here in Europe is that most divers on that level go over their certification limits within less than 5 dives. The 1/6th rule is the first that is overtaken. Then it is the no deco and the no jump. So then I always advice to combine all cave courses together. What you see then is that people are more carefull and they have learned how to do things right. But a lot of people who take the cave diving courses in Europe are already technical divers at least on advanced nitrox level. They don't start with a single tank. I also advice people to do adv. nitrxo before doing a cave course. I never gave or will give intro to cave with a single tank.
I also don't want to see an fundies/essentials/basics of tech course as mandatory, it can be usefull for a lot of people, but not for all a needed course to progress.
I like the option to have steps between courses like from adv. nitrox the step to add some helium before going to the 60m trimix cert, but only as optional.
So conclusion about your question: if you instructor is just a cave diver and cavern instructor, he cannot bring you on a cave dive at the next level. If the instructor is at least an intro to cave instructor, he can.
If it is just a friend who wants to take you on a cave dive, I would advice not to do, but it is probably not forbidden by law.
And sometimes you get in strange situations, only single tank options, a guide that has no cave cert, but he is the only way to bring you in a cave and you are a full cave diver. Then if such a thing happens, be careful, but I know, most divers will not say no to it. But use your brains.
OP
Hi all, sorry for the delay in posting but I passed my written evaluation and with that I am now a newly minted PADI Cavern diver! I'm so excited and the hard work has paid off. Cavern is definitely unique, I am looking forward to going back. As is the case when doing certifications, I'm so focused on the skills and task at hand that I really didn't get enough time to fully enjoy and appreciate the dives.
Oh I also just realized that I have entered the realm of a technical diver! (Please correct me if I'm wrong) Even still I know I still need to fine tune a few things and when January rolls around, I plan on hitting the lake and start practicing sidemount. I earned TDI Technical Sidemount about two weeks before I took cavern, so the end of the year was very busy for me diving wise. I'm going to put in about 25-50 dives in sidemount, then soon afterwards take the TDI ANDP course.
Looking forward to what 2024 has to offer. Best wishes and may you all have a prosperous, healthy and Happy New Year!!!
Oh I also just realized that I have entered the realm of a technical diver! (Please correct me if I'm wrong) Even still I know I still need to fine tune a few things and when January rolls around, I plan on hitting the lake and start practicing sidemount. I earned TDI Technical Sidemount about two weeks before I took cavern, so the end of the year was very busy for me diving wise. I'm going to put in about 25-50 dives in sidemount, then soon afterwards take the TDI ANDP course.
Looking forward to what 2024 has to offer. Best wishes and may you all have a prosperous, healthy and Happy New Year!!!
Capt Jim Wyatt
Hanging at the 10 Foot Stop
Staff member
ScubaBoard Business Sponsor
Scuba Instructor
OP
As for the sidemount class:
I had become curious about technical diving and after doing research I discovered the TDI Intro to Technical Diving course. In October I signed up, then I settled on sidemount as I have limited shoulder flexibility and I like the fact that in sidemount the valves are right in front of you, so it's easier to operate and troubleshoot.
During the class I was the only diver who opted for sidemount and the other 3 divers opted for backmount doubles. It worked out great for me because when I did the Open water portion I was the only diver so it was like a private lesson. Diving sidemount was awkward at first but I ended up getting used to it and I was getting my buoyancy dialed in. I didn't realize it at the time but he took me through the entire sidemount course. I made use of my time by asking questions and going through drills until I was comfortable. An added benefit was that my instructor primarily dives sidemount so I had a wealth of experience to draw from. I also believe that he gave me more information and skills to perform than is normally required. I soaked it all up AND was appreciative of his efforts.
As soon as I finished the course, I spent the next month working overtime to so I could buy my own setup and once I had all the required gear I signed up for the TDI Technical sidemount course which was about $300. Once again I had the fortune to have the same instructor AND be the only diver. Prior to starting the course, we planned an extra day just to go over setting up my gear. For about 4 hours we unpacked and set up my harness, regulators, tanks and computers. He taught me how to maintain and set up the gear and afterwards we began to set up the gear to my body for optimum streamlining. Oh the harness I chose was the Hollis Katana 2 and HOG (D3 DIN w/classic 2nd stage) regulators for both tanks and the deco bottle.
The ITT course prepared me for the actual sidemount course. Skills were donning tanks standing in water, underwater and on land. S-drills, staging bottles, simulated deco, planning and gas management and I may be missing a few. Since I went through ITT with the same instructor, we didn't spend much time on classwork and I aced the exam! The following day I had 3 open water dives and afterwards, I earned my certification.
Prior to taking ITT and sidemount, I was diving solo at my local lake to tune up skills and to practice. Because there is a degree of self-sufficiency in technical diving I decided become "legal" and take the SDI Solo course. I had completed the pool and course work earlier so after I finished my sidemount open water dives, I completed my open water for Solo. So that weekend I earned Sidemount and Solo certs.
Similar threads
