Really? Even mantigue Island? My first time at Camiguin we did both sides of white island (black forest and Kilambing South). Black Forest was unique with the Corals, Kilambing wasn't anything too special. But the next time I was there we went to Mantigue and that was amazing. Turtle point definitely lived up to its name. Maybe things have changed in the decade or so since you were there? Or just you have a different history of experiences to compare it to, which is more likely.I went to Camiguin(2009) with my non diving mate. I am afraid the diving was very ordinary by Philippines standard. But the island is indeed very very quiet, there are seven volcanoes so many walking trails are available. Guide is highly recommended.
My non diving mate managed to borrow a mountain bike and he has a blast especially the traffic was very very light.
Lack of development is probably the saving grace for the islander!
Development there is growing. Especially with the airport and the numerous topside things you can do now (waterfalls, hot and cold springs, giant clam sanctuary). There's even a Gaisano now, across from the market in Mambajao. The only thing lacking is the nightlife, but for some that's a blessing. Not sure, I'll ask around next month when I get there.