Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
The stage use was a one shot thingy ... normally, my steel 100cu is plenty. Since the stage btl, (40) becomes pos buoyant when empty, I would use it last, reserving enough air in my main for bcd and drysuit in my main.For redundancy you don’t need 3 tanks. Why don’t you start and breath down with the stage to a certain pressure and then start using your single tank/backgas ?
Or just use doubles instead of 3 tanks. If I would use doubles/sidemount for a cave dive I don’t need a third tank for redundancy.
You don’t need a third bottle for redundancy which is not part of your gasplanning if you’re already using 2 tanks for a rec dive.The stage use was a one shot thingy ... normally, my steel 100cu is plenty. Since the stage btl, (40) becomes pos buoyant when empty, I would use it last, reserving enough air in my main for bcd and drysuit in my main.
The redundancy is in the pony. The stage btl adds gas to gas planning.
When it happened to my son, on a Scubapro MK5, it was rust from the tank which clogged entirely the concave filter... A rented tank, of course, which was possibly badly maintained or had water inside.How the hell did a downstream valve fail closed?
Ya, guilty as charged. But I think you missed my point, the question was "recreational" pony bottles. You're comfortable and squared away to do a 120' dive with a larger bottle and back-up, it may be a "recreational" dive to you, but it sure as heck aint a recreational dive to 99% of the "recreational" divers you see on dive boats in the Keys (or anywhere else).No! your GUE is showing and not the modern GUE but the one more akin to 20+years ago when it was more GI3/DIR. Where I am a dive to 120' on a single is a common occurrence and more than 50% of the divers will be carrying a pony.
Just because there are bad divers out there does not make a 120' dive a tech dive. I am not a technical diver, but have gone over 100' many times. I never hit ndl and don't go into overhead environments, which is what makes a dive a tech dive. These are all rec dives.Ya, guilty as charged. But I think you missed my point, the question was "recreational" pony bottles. You're comfortable and squared away to do a 120' dive with a larger bottle and back-up, it may be a "recreational" dive to you, but it sure as heck aint a recreational dive to 99% of the "recreational" divers you see on dive boats in the Keys (or anywhere else).
I've done plenty of dives deep on single Alum 80's and came up within a large safety margin of gas, but I'm not going to state it was a "recreational" dive. I was diving the top of the deep Jupiter ledge (north of Hole in the Wall) with a "recreational" diver, I had to chase him to 140' and pull him off the bottom, he was "lost". Had to rescue a woman 2 years ago on a "recreational" wreck dive with a max depth of 115, should have never been on that dive. I was on a dive club dive not too long ago, full boat, all the divers had the latest equipment, even some BP/wing set ups, after watching them on 2 shallow reefs, not one of them i would feel comfortable taking below 60'.....that's why I stopped diving cattle boats for the most part, too much like a horror show.
My point is that most recreational divers should not be going below 80' (and even that is pushing it for a lot of divers) for the most part, going deeper the rules change and it becomes a gray area of rec/tec. We as tech/experienced divers need to make that clear to new divers. When they ask a question about recreational diving, keep it to recreational profiles. More gear, more task loading. My .02 cents.
What was your total bottom time? And what is your definition of "just under 1K"?My last was a wall dive in an abandoned quarry. We got to 126'. I was on 30% nitrox. My myself and my buddy had al80's and surfaced (after 5 min safety stops) with just under 1k psi. Was this somehow a tech dive to you?
980psi if you need specifics. 31 minutes, but not sure why that matters, as I was never had less than 5 min of ndl time remaining.What was your total bottom time? And what is your definition of "just under 1K"?
Everybody I know that does that still has an octo.For those of you who dive single tank plus pony for redundancy only, do you 1. Still have two second stages on your back air plus additional on pony?