On a dive trip to Anguilla, the conditions were right for us to dive El Buen Consejo (The Good Counsel)
https://www.aahsanguilla.com/uploads/7/3/7/1/7371196/el_conjo.pdf
The divemaster/ shop owner was busy with some "new" students, none of whom had more than a handful of dives. Our instructions were to stay close, as they'd seen an extremely large tiger shark in the channel on the last visit a few days before.
The wreck of El Buen Consejo is classified as a living museum, which means that nothing can be removed. Any artifact that is handled, must be returned to where it came from under penalty of law. In the predive briefing, we were told that any violations were subject to an automatic 10 years in prison AND $100,000 U.S. fine...they aren't playing. We were subject to search when we returned to the dock. Understood.
So, we got in the water and the first thing you see are two fluke anchors with the eyes pointing toward the wreck. The bottom was littered with cannons, pewter plates, ballast stones, encrusted cannonballs, encrusted copper pins (used to nail the hull together). There's also glass buttons, wads of pitch that helped glue the hull to keep it watertight, broken china, and even pewter utensils. We also found brass religious medallions that the monks were trading the natives for their gold & silver (what a deal, right?) I was amazed and blown away at the same time. My wife, however, considers shipwrecks human garbage and she has zero interest in them. She got bored quickly and was prompting me to go find some fun fish/critters. We found a peacock flounder and went to get a closer look. The flounder wasn't having any part of that, so it swam up off the bottom and headed towards deeper water. I spotted it again, but as soon as the flounder saw us, it took off again and gave us the slip. We were now slightly over the edge of the channel which we were supposed to avoid. We turned and started back up to the shallower flat. Something in the reef caught my eye. It looked like a couple of brass candlesticks encrusted in the reef, they were covered with a light whispy coating of green algae. I moved closer and rubbed at the algae, which went away immediately. Instead of candlesticks, I realized they were stacks of gold coins(!!!). I tried to lift them or turn them to get them out of the reef concretion. They wouldn't budge, but I could tell there were more stacked behind the two stacks showing. I banged on my tank with my knife handle in a frenzy to get my wife's attention. She appeared over the lip of the reef and with an exasperated look, she turned her palms up signaling "WHAT?". I motioned for here to come see and again, she signalled "What?". All I could think to do was rub my fingertips together like "money!", but she didn't get it. As I tried to chip the concretion away with the handle of me knife, she saw the gold. Her eyes got huge, then she held up an index finger and shook it back and forth, like "No,no,no". About that time, the divemaster popped over the lip of the channel, asking if we were OK. He'd heard the frenzied banging and feared the worst. After I confirmed that we were o.k., I motioned for him to come see what I'd found with the rubbing fingertips move. His eyes almost popped out of his head when he saw the stacked gold coins. I got the same "No,no,no" finger wag from him too. He looked hesitantly towards the blue water and motioned for us to follow him back up to the shallows. When we got to the boat, he told me not to mention it to the others and that he'd report to the authorities. The thought of a $100,000 fine and 10 years in the hole kept going through my mind. Whatever, I knew it was off limits to me, though I was thrilled with my find.
The next year, I went online looking for that dive shop and it was no longer in operation. I couldn't find any current information about the shop owner either. I don't know if he went back, collected the gold, took the money and ran, or if the hurricane that hit after our visit ran him out of business.
Even though I don't have anything to show for it, those gold coins were the coolest find of my dive career, so far.
Jim