I don't see any reason why you would need mix for a Cave 1 class.
If that is what s/he is used to, why not?
Y'know, some of us do different things because it works for us. TSandM had an "ah-ha" when she was diving air at 100. She said she won't dive there or below without trimix.
I have yet to experience narcosis (instructors / friends agree). But I do prefer to dive nitrox or suck on nitrox at the safety stop, due to subclinical DCS symptoms.