Why not BP/W for Beginner?

[AbyssalPlains]

While you will find 100% of DIR divers in back plates, it's simply not true that BP&W = DIR.

I talk with many new BP&W divers every week from all parts of the country and around the world. Many either have no idea of what DIR means, or they have a negative opinion, usually based on miss information. A minority know of "DIR" and a smaller minority are actually headed down that path.

Tobin

I second that.

 

[TSandM]

Originally Posted by bfw:
. Without getting into who is right, BP/W enthusiasts tend to support a philosophy called DIR

This is actually almost funny. Here in the Seattle area, there are a TON of people diving BP/W setups who would spit at you if you accused them of being DIR . . .

 

[David_57]

I am 100% in agreement with cool_hardware52 like I said check on what DIR have to say about banded wings which I dive with its kind of amusing.

 

[Mambo Dave]

The reason your LDS wants you in a jacket is so they can "upgrade" you to a more expensive BC in a year or so. Don't go for it. I put all of my adult OW students in a BP/W from day one. If you purchase a good plate and wing now, you will never have to buy another buoyancy control system, it will grow with you as your diving needs and skills increase. I only recommend two BP/W manufacturers, Halcyon and DSS. BTW, Welcome to diving and ScubaBoard. Good luck and safe diving. almtree: Bob

+1 to Bob's reply, save for the limited (albeit great) list of BP/W component manufacturers.