For that to be a debatable topic, it would have to in fact be something that could be reasonably supported as well as reasonably opposed. Else it isn't debatable.
This is not reasonably supportable.
If you want something scuba related though, consider the question of if scuba divers should be licensed by the state, or if there should be federal standards for scuba training, or if there should be a law that divers must be certified, and so on. There are plenty of legitimately debatable questions related to the scuba industry.
Agree completely.
How about this simple, easily debated topic: Boat operators (personal or otherwise) must be licensed just like car drivers. Like - pass a written test in which they have to know the purpose and rules of a dive flag! :shocked2: