Soggy
Contributor
I agree with pretty much everything you've said. Dropping weights is almost never the right choice. When discussing usage of my weighting system with a new buddy, I preface it with, "If you want to kill me, pull here." What doesn't help is the agencies telling students, "95% of divers found dead underwater had their weight belts still on." Well, who cares? Would it have actually have saved them if they dropped the weights!?
With my BP/Wings, dropping the belt has to be very intentional, since the crotch strap holds it in....unbuckle waist-strap, remove crotch strap, unbuckle weight belt, drop weight belt, ascend way to fast to the surface.
My only argument is that there is a better place to put a marker buoy than on your weight belt. The butt D-ring being a good place (if you have one). For one thing, it makes losing your weightbelt that much more likely. I can envision a situation where something catches on the dring on your weight belt and through some fluke, pulls the whole thing off. Now you're in a big cluster-F...
With my BP/Wings, dropping the belt has to be very intentional, since the crotch strap holds it in....unbuckle waist-strap, remove crotch strap, unbuckle weight belt, drop weight belt, ascend way to fast to the surface.
My only argument is that there is a better place to put a marker buoy than on your weight belt. The butt D-ring being a good place (if you have one). For one thing, it makes losing your weightbelt that much more likely. I can envision a situation where something catches on the dring on your weight belt and through some fluke, pulls the whole thing off. Now you're in a big cluster-F...