What reg, what reg...

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

PrincessOfPower

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
Location
San Diego, CA
# of dives
500 - 999
Hey

So I'm in the midst of researching what reg to buy, and I thought I'd see what sorts of opions I could get here.

Sooo, I ask, what reg do you all reccommend. Here's the specs on what I need:

- Reliable. Week after week. Dive after dive.

- Easily serviceable (or maybe more accureately, easily serviceable after easy to find servicing clinic).

- Suitable for cold water and for more technical diving.

I'm hovering over the ATX200 at the moment...
 
For what you describe I don't think you can go wrong with Apeks. Good old British craftmanship and all that. My (XTX) breathes great and those that use it for deeper, colder and more technical dives seem to swear by them. Only thing to think about is whether you have enough Apeks knowledge locally to teach you what you want to know.

And I'm not sure how easy you'll find it to get an ATX anymore, they seem to have been totally replaced by the XTX. If you find one, get it, as far as I know they are identical apart from the ability to charge the consumer for a function they are almost certainly not going to need.

Hope you get what you want.
 
Apeks is owned by Aqualung and Aqualung like many other companies controls their parts sales pretty religiously. Similarly, service clinics are rare and if held require you to be shop sponsored/employed.

Scubapro has the same parts control and shop sponsored clinic attendence issues, but parts are easier to find through sources such as e-bay as they are muhc more common and much more comonly sold through grey market cources. Also Pete Wolfinger used o be Scubapro's technical guru and wrote all their tech manuals. He now operates Peterbuilt tools:

www.scubtools.com

And he sells a very good primer for reg repair:

http://www.scubatools.com/RegSavvy.html

The advantage is that the book contains many drawnings and explanations from the Scubapro tech training materials and is a good way to get to know Scubapro (as well as other) designs. He also goes into great detail on what is needed to service regulators in terms of tools, diagnosing problems, servicing, adjusting, and testing. Vance Harlow's book available through airspeed press is also a good primer for do it yourself regulator repair.

If you want simple, reliable and easy to service it is just about impossible to beat a Scubapro MK 2 R190 or MK 2 R295, especially if you pick up a few tools from Peterbuilt.

If you want a reg that is suitable for technical diving, the Mk 17 G250, MK 17 S600, or mK 17 X650 would be my first choice. The Mk 25 first stage also works very well with all of the above mentioned second stages as well, but is not as relaible in extremely cold water (below 45 degrees F). May tech divers however prefer the Mk 25's hose routing options.

An easier to service, very reliable and much less expensive alternative to the Mk 25 would be a used MK 10 or Mk 10 Plus. It offers the same general layout in terms of hose routing but has a lower parts count, is easier to service, parts are easily found used and a Mk 10 or Mk 10 Plus can be found around $100 in excellent condition. A G250 second stage can also be found used for $100-$150 and the combination will offer exceptional performance.

Alternatively, there are a couple companies that sell regs who also do not control parts sales making it fairly simple for end users to get parts to do their own maintenence. But it is hard to say how long they will continue selling parts for and supporting a particular model while both Aqualung and Scubapro have excellent records for supporting discontinued regulator models for decades, and Scubapro has a track record of improving and providing upgrades for discontinued models .

If you do go the service your own reg route, be prepared to spend $200-$300 for tools unless you already have a decent collection of hand tools, a suitably sized torque wrench, etc. If you already have adequate hand tools, you will just need $100 or so in specialty tools.
 
Scubapro Mark 17 with any of there balanced second stages
Mark 17 is a good balanced cold water reg
So if you want to grow you have a reg that will cover all your needs.
Serviced where ever you dive,scubapro is used around the world and by most dive shops.
There are alot of very good regs,but i chose scubapro because of its reputation as a dependable smoothe breather ,they provide parts for there regs for many years.
so you dont have to worry about it being Phased out.
unless Mares buys them out. Ha Ha
 
squidster:
There are alot of very good regs,but i chose scubapro because of its reputation as a dependable smoothe breather ,they provide parts for there regs for many years.
so you dont have to worry about it being Phased out.
unless Mares buys them out. Ha Ha
Mares buying Scubapro...what a terrible thought. :11:
 
I own two Apek regulators and like them very much. I also own Oceanic and Zeagle and like them as well. The atx 200 is a great regulator. The xtx200 might be a better option though b/c all the low/med pressure ports are 3/8" while one of the low/med pressure ports is 1/2" on the atx.
 
You can't go wrong with Apeks but Dive Rite used to sell kits for their regs online.
 

Back
Top Bottom