What makes one cave instructor more expensive than the other (in their own mind?)

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Well I laid out what I would do in post #64 and picking an specific course or worse agency isn't part of the equation at all.

Shocking as it might be you can mix and match too!
1) GUE-F
2) NSS-CDS Cavern and Basic Cave backmount
3) (couple years go by)
4) sidemount demo day
5) another summer diving
6) PSIA Full cave sidemount

There are actually instructors who teach for multiple agencies as well. You could in theory do #1 and #2 with the same instructor for instance.

Only thing I see wrong with this is doesnt Nss-cds require you to continue past basic within 1 year?
 
Only thing I see wrong with this is doesnt Nss-cds require you to continue past basic within 1 year?

Finishing full cave within 1 year is no longer a requirement for NSS-CDS, they changed the standard two or three years ago.
 
Only thing I see wrong with this is doesnt Nss-cds require you to continue past basic within 1 year?
Basic is an unlimited never expiring cert
Apprentice still has a 1yr expiration/timelimit
Cave Diver Training
Full is expiry free

Was more a theoretical mix and match vs. deciding on an agency track (how many times have people lobbied against that?!?) which locks you into a preset path. Only GUE really does that.
 
I see a lot split courses in 3 courses: cavern, intro, full (sometimes appr). Here in Europe this is not done mostly.
Cavern is not teached here, we don't have real caverns. If instructors teach cavern, you have to turn around in 20-25m and there is nothing to see, the dive will take less than 5 minutes. If there is a cavern, that is completely unexpectable when you go to a cave, it can be there when starting a dive and gone when ending a dive. So yes, sometimes people get a cavern card, but with only cavern you cannot do anything. So I teach at least to intro to cave. But some go to full cave as this is allowed also. And with only cavern as cert, you have to break your limits already in your course or as first dive after your course.

I did the same when I started cavediving, cavern, intro and full in 7 days (16 dives) and it was really nice to do with a good instructor.
Intro to cave is a course that limits you soo much here that divers will go over their limits in less than 10 dives after the course, agency independent (I have seen this with all agencies, some divers break their limits on their first dive already). In some mines you can only dive with a full cave cert. So another reason to do the full course.

But I want people to have at least adv. nitrox when doing a full cave course. This has to do with the depth of some caves (30m). With air you will get into deco. With nitrox also sometimes. Most dives will not give you any deco, but it is a pity to shorten dives because of.

I never asked a diver to do a course over, but sometimes they told me (happely) they did not learn a lot in their previous course. So we do it then again, but I do not charge or give them a new cert. I always go some extra days to the caves and if not, I have the option to finish in a slatemine.
The first instructor who would say I have to do a course over would be a bad instructor in my eyes. I would choose for another one. But I never had this discussions myself. I only sometimes hear about it.

If you want to do cave in sidemount or ccr, some agencies don't have this option. This is also something to consider.

My own instructor reased his prices from 1500 dollar to over 2500 dollar now over the years. In Europe you pay mostly 1200-1500 euro (so in dollars a little bit more) from nothing to full/technical cave excluding gases, fuel, etc. 600-750 for the intro to cave part (nothing to intro to cave, sometimes you also get a cavern cert) and 750 for the full/technical cave part is normal if you split the course into 2 courses.
 

Back
Top Bottom