What is safer overall, recreational diving or snowmobiling??
- Thread starter CoopAir
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
K
KeithG
Guest
Snowmobiling, snowboarding, snow skiing, snowman making,... All the the same. Just crazy pastimes for those Canucks waiting for their 2 months of summer to show up.
Glad I have been in Jamaica the last few weeks...
clownfishsydney
Contributor
In Australia, snowmobiling would definitely be safer. Why? I am pretty sure that there is no place a lay person could legally ride a snowmobile.
iffn ya be an eejut ya can keel yaself walkin cross a road. A Scuba kit or a snowmobile aint dangerous.Its the eejut that uses em that makes em dangerous.
Bowling......
This points out that a lot depends upon the kind of snowmobiling you are doing. The OP limited the diving to relatively shallow, benign diving. There is a big difference between snowmobiling across a big, wide open field and snowmobiling across an avalanche zone above timberline near the continental divide. The 5 snowboarders who were killed a few days ago were expert snowboarders participating in an event which is, ironically, partially designed to stress back country safety. It was a huge slide, and there was nothing they could have done any differently to save themselves--except not go there at all. They had all the skills. They had all the equipment. And yes, snowmobilers in Colorado go to such places as well.
I know someone who was also snowmobiling in unfamiliar terrain high in the Colorado Rockies. He went through a stand of trees and realized he had just gone off a cliff with a 50 foot drop. He lived, but he was a mass of broken bones.
Cosimo_Zaretti
Registered
Well all the good ski spots are in the national park, but there must be plenty of private farmland that's above the snowline in winter. No idea where you'd even find a snowmobile in Australia although I understand emergency services around Thredbo have a few. Riding dirt bikes in the snow seems more likely. Why let a rare day of snowfall spoil an afternoon's hoonery?
clownfish60
Contributor
Statistics? (I have never seen a diver hit a tree at 60mph!) 
SCUBA (worldwide)
1 out of every 211,864 dives ending in a fatality does not seem so great a number when compared with the fatality rates of other activities. (per DAN)
Snowmobiles (just in North America)
Each year snowmobile accidents produce approximately 200 deaths and 14,000 injuries.
SCUBA (worldwide)
1 out of every 211,864 dives ending in a fatality does not seem so great a number when compared with the fatality rates of other activities. (per DAN)
Snowmobiles (just in North America)
Each year snowmobile accidents produce approximately 200 deaths and 14,000 injuries.
pjhansman
Contributor
Statistics? (I have never seen a diver hit a tree at 60mph!)
SCUBA (worldwide)
1 out of every 211,864 dives ending in a fatality does not seem so great a number when compared with the fatality rates of other activities. (per DAN)
Snowmobiles (just in North America)
Each year snowmobile accidents produce approximately 200 deaths and 14,000 injuries.
I don't think this accurately compares the two. Where I live, there are easily 1000 times more snowmobilers than divers, and they go on hundreds of rides per year while the average diver in my area does less than 50 dives per year. In Florida, the opposite is probably true.
I am not saying one is more dangerous than the other, just that you cannot infer it from this data.
Incidentally, I have never seen a snowmobiler die from DCS.
Similar threads
