Well I just don't agree with some of this at all. The boat diving "specialty" can actually be a fun and informative class- Not everyone that learns to dive has the benefit of diving from a boat during their training. In fact there are quite a few divers that will spend their first year of diving inland, doing shore dives in a quarry. I can't count how many discussions on SB have been about how some divers act on boats, poorly or properly. Now I certainly agree that it doesn't require a card and I suppose that some folks can get this info for free but why don't we open this up to some of the DM's working boats and find out if they'd like to see divers showing up with a little better understanding of what it takes to dive from a boat, things like getting on and off with your gear, how to act, where to p, how much to bring and what to leave at home,etc. etc. Some people learn better in a structured environment than by osmosis. Plus some of the info being passed around on the tail ends of diveboats by those that think they are in the know is just plain bad info.
So actually a boat diver specialty just might be the ticket for some.
So actually a boat diver specialty just might be the ticket for some.