Ultrasonic Cleaning: suitable containers

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

rsingler

Scuba Instructor, Tinkerer in Brass
Staff member
ScubaBoard Sponsor
Messages
9,502
Reaction score
14,484
Location
Cambria, California
# of dives
500 - 999
So you've finally got an ultrasonic! Maybe a $150 import that you'll replace in 13 months (because the warranty is 12), or a $600 used Branson that'll last for years, but either way, you're now in the big leagues. But you don't have enough money for two.
You've got your 4% phosphoric acid, or 5% citric acid, or 50:50 household vinegar solution for verdigris removal, and your scent-free dishwashing solution (or Extreme Simple Green, or, or...) to emulsify hydrocarbons, but which one do you put in the U/S basin?
Me, I use the acid. Verdigris removal is the one step that seems to benefit best from the occasional U/S boost. But YMMV. In any case, what happens when you have some stubborn junk that needs some ultrasonic detergent assist to lift off? You can pour out the acid and rinse and pour in the detergent, but that quickly gets to be a PITA.
Most of us just float a container with the required solution in our U/S basin and let it do its thing. Some even just use water in the U/S as a medium to carry sound waves and always float a container of acid or detergent in the bath. I was chatting with @Tanks A Lot after our most recent Seminar (thank you, @Tanks A Lot for your superb input!), and he corrected me about floating a glass container in the bath. I had taught that a plastic yogurt cup was inferior, because it's flexible walls would absorb the sound waves. He said "No, Rob", and something about "acoustic impedance", but I'll let him weigh in with his better store of knowledge.
Anyway, I still disagreed, and went to Grok3, which supported glass over plastic. When we chatted again, he laughed about AI and said that Grok was incorrect.

So...
I did an experiment.
Here are three strips of aluminum foil which had been suspended in the ultrasonic for 26 minutes.
On the left, a strip just hung in my phosphoric acid bath heated to 60C. In the middle, a strip hung in a plastic yogurt cup, and on the right a sturdy glass pickle jar.
20250708_091100(1).jpg

Well, oops! 26 min in hot acid just completely ate the foil in the basin. In the middle (yogurt container), two chunks chewed out of the plastic cup strip, and on the right (glass jar) a chunk and some edges chewed out of the glass jar strip. What did I (re)learn? Don't leave your regs in the acid unattended, or your chrome will be gone! But I couldn't really answer the question about which container was better, because the results were too similar. Clearly, ANY container is a huge barrier, so that speaks to choosing one solution or the other, rather than using water and always floating a cup of some material. Those transducers have a good, but limited lifetime, so direct exposure to sound waves is clearly better.

So I repeated the experiment with a shorter (10 min) exposure:
Here's hot Phosphoric acid with no container:
20250708_091017(1).jpg

Here's hot acid in a plastic 1 quart yogurt container:
20250708_091029(1).jpg

Here's hot acid in a glass jar:
20250708_091036(1).jpg

As you can see, no barrier is clearly better. But if you have to have a barrier because you're floating incompatible detergent in a basin full of acid (or vice versa), the plastic WAS a little better than glass, Grok notwithstanding. Here's a toast to @Tanks A Lot and real knowledge, compared with AI and scraping the Internet.

But the diminution in force was significant, so the search is now on for a better plastic.
Here's my first, next experiment (because it was sitting in the recycle container in the kitchen).
20250708_093449(1).jpg

Maybe thinner will be better. I'm open to suggestions.

Hey, @Tanks A Lot ! Teach us about acoustic impedance!
 
I actually have been sticking to plastic cups since you first gave the tip last year in the seminar — glass seemed too rigid for my taste (and I extrapolated a bit from speaker cabinet design and audio design guides); but never tried it (glass) myself
Here's my first, next experiment (because it was sitting in the recycle container in the kitchen).
20250708_093449(1).jpg

Maybe thinner will be better. I'm open to suggestions.
oh I really like that form — would be great to separate parts from scratching at eachother

Hey, @Tanks A Lot ! Teach us about acoustic impedance!
Oh yes please! that’s something I’d love to hear a lot about (and never expected to read on SB, maybe on a synthesizer forum in context of recording rooms😂)
 
Metal?

Not for dive gear, but motorcycle chain. Non-O-ring. For service I soak it in a gallon of WD40. The metal gallon can it comes in. I've been known to set that can in the ultrasonic cleaner (with water on the outside of the can) and run it. Chain comes out much cleaner. Inside of the ultrasound stays clean as well. It's the cheap metal gallon can, nothing super thick.
 
oh I really like that form — would be great to separate parts from scratching at eachother
Back when I took Rob's class (👌) I went down this road for my cheap, Harbor Freight, Chinese US machine. These fit nicely and support on the rim of the US if not fully floating and have 3 sections to separate small/fragile parts from the bruisers ...

As a side benefit they make nice parts trays between steps.

Original post link
Cleaning supplies:
20220913_131013.jpg


Target find: Bento Box segmented trays for cleaning - use in US w/ water bath:
20220913_131028.jpg

I use similar products for cleaner and lube for other things (that go BANG :wink:.)
 
I’ve been using silicone soft bags (marketed as reusable) to do this occasionally. I’ve been meaning to try large silicone ice-cube trays, for maximum parts-organizing potential, but haven’t got that far yet.
 
I’ve been using silicone soft bags (marketed as reusable) to do this occasionally. I’ve been meaning to try large silicone ice-cube trays, for maximum parts-organizing potential, but haven’t got that far yet.
Bruh, that’s the energy you’re giving right now
00C681D0-B543-4048-984F-8607D14E3B24.jpeg


do you have an example of the 1st product?
 
I've been using ziplock bags. Not as durable as a solid container, but I use little solution with it. Being transparent i can also lift it quickly and check for progress from every angle. Seems to work ok for now.
 
What if you got both an L&R and an Elma sonic? Maybe a third for rinse water? I'll have to work on that third one.

Now I just need one of the slide vise things...
 
Back
Top Bottom