@OWIC647 If I said anything that was factually incorrect, I certainly apologize. If I did, I'm not sure what it was, so please let me know.
The Highland tank straps I was referring to were these:
Store - Vintage Double Hose
It does say they are made by XS Scuba.
I got the set I used to have from Dive Gear Express.
Highland Tank Straps, Quick Release w/ Cam Buckle (PAIR)
The biggest problem I had with them was that the hook is too deep. When adjusted to the right tension, just opening the cam didn't create enough slack to easily unhook the strap. It's an issue that has been well-documented here on SB:
Highland/XS scuba Cambands.....Doesn't seem right
DGX is awesome, and QR tank strap PIF
Genaric ScubaPro style tank strap experiences?
This thread even talks about the issue and shows
@Akimbo's solution (on page 3) of cutting part of the hook off, to make them more usable.
Do you have either of these tank straps?
I mean, if you can't easily unhook the end, then how are they any better than a normal cam band?
With the DGX version of the ScubaPro-style, I like the following things that are advantages (to me) over the Highland ones:
- I can easily completely undo the strap to remove the BCD from the tank without lifting the BCD.
- The length of the strap is easier to adjust (to me). It's just some velcro. I have always found precise adjustment of a cam band tightness to be more difficult than the SP-style adjustment.
- The DGX SP-style has the bitter end of the strap where it tucks in between the tank band and the tank itself. So, during a dive there is no end of the strap to come loose from velcro and float around.
- The Highland straps come with a rubber pad that you position under the buckle to protect the tank finish. It is a PITA to use and position every time. The DGX SP-style has part of the webbing that extends to under the buckle, so you don't really have to do anything to make sure the tank finish is protected when you fasten the buckle.
- They are now only $15 each ($30 per pair), from Dive Gear Express. They used to be $20 each, but the price dropped sometime recently.
DGX Tank Strap, Quick Release with S/S Hinge Buckle