Zeagle Eagle
Contributor
Maybe I use a different terminology. By corrugated, I mean the hose from BC to inflator. By LPI hose, I mean the LP hose from regulator LP port to inflator.
I agree that given everything the same, one less hose is more streamline. But one less hose piggy back with hose that is not optimal in length for streamline defect the purpose of one less hose. Air2 is the perfect example here IMO. When using standard inflator, I (most people I dive with) use 12-13" corrugated hose. This length is good enough for all kind of inflation and deflation, I can also inflate both wing and drysuit at the same time. And when in horizontal, the inflator doesn't dangle pass my body much. But there is no way I can breath of this length comfortably with full head moment if an Air2 is attached there.
When I haven't used Air2 before, I know that in order to get full range of head motion, I need the corrugated hose to be about 22-24" in length. In order to remove 1 hose, you need to elongate another hose. And I know for the fact with 22" corrugated hose, the inflator will dangle far off my body because I have a picture of myself with 18" corrugated hose, and it dangles.
From what I have observed, the most streamline config is 22" backup on bungee, primary donate on long hose. "long hose" can either be 40" or so router under arm, or 5"/7" hogarthan style. There will be no hose sticking/bowing/dangling out with this type of config.
I think I understand what you are saying. My hose with the Octo Z on it is the same length as it ever was. Would I want to do a whole dive using it. No. It also has a Dive Alert Plus on it as well. I didn't change the length as it is not necessary to get me safely to the surface. I don't share it. It reaches my mouth just fine and I can inflate and deflate at will. I don't have to raise it over my head as the top of the valve that attaches to the BCD is also a dump valve. I can just pull on it. I think I have 4 ways to dump on my Stiletto depending on what position I am in and where the biggest bubble is.
Incidentally, We are talking about a situation that most divers never see. You may go a whole career and never need to share air. I am not against an Octopus. I am against dragging it through the coral which many people inadvertently do.
Now, remember I am a warm water recreational diver. Most of the time I don't even wear a wet suit. Maybe a rash guard if there are jellies. I can't stand all that crap bungeed to me and wraped around my neck.
Me:


You:
