I'm having the same indecision problem right now...I bought my basic stuff (mask, fins, boots, gloves, hood, snorkel) from my LDS before I took my OW class. I purchased a (barely) used BC from a friend of mine that got me into diving. Now the time has come to get my reg and my console....I will be buying a Poseidon Odin/Jetstream. My LDS has it listed for about $430...Leisurepro has it listed for $249.
I want to buy from my LDS because I value the relationship I have with it. I get great service from them. I had a zipper break on my boots, and I walked in and he tossed me a new pair of the rack, no questions asked. And he even changed up the size for me as the pair I had were a little too small.
But, I have a hard time spending $200 more on something just to buy it from my LDS.....
I know I'm more than likely going to buy from my LDS, just because I know and trust them (especially with something as important as my regulator), but it kinda hurts to know I'm passing up such savings....which I realize may not be the greatest savings when I have to give it up to Leisurepro for service....argh.
Maybe I can ask him to see if he can come down on the price a little bit...that would at least make me feel better about it!