Shark kills South African spear fisherman

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Guys the statistics are great and all, but trying explaining that to their families.

We know its a rare occurrence, but it happens....don't sugar coat it with how unlikely of an event it is. It is a rather sad story, but I'm not surprised....killing fish in waters known for the Great Whites...time to go to Leisurepro and get a shark repellant. :/
 
it's not sugar-coating, it's perspective

simply because every single time a shark hurts someone makes the news,
the coverage obscures how rare deaths due to shark attack really are

of course, statistics don't matter when your son is killed by a shark,
but that wasn't my point. a lot more sons are killed by automobiles,
and those parents grieve just as much.
 
Here is CNN's report of the incident, a spearfisherman killed by a shark:

JOHANNESBURG, South Africa (Reuters) -- A South African spear fisherman has been killed by a shark after a struggle in which he and his partner attempted to fight it off with their spear guns, marine officials said on Monday.

Henri Murray, 22, was the second spear fisherman to be killed by a shark in South African waters in the past 19 months.

Media reported on Monday that Murray had attempted to fend the shark off with his spear gun, fighting it off twice before it snatched him in its jaws. His fishing partner also tried to ward the creature off.

"His partner shot the shark with a spear," said Meriel Bartlett, a spokeswoman with the National Sea Rescue Institute.

The incident occurred near Cape Town on Saturday. The shark was presumed to be a great white, the ocean's most feared predator, which is common in the region's waters.

Off South Africa it is illegal to spear fish in scuba gear so divers must hold their breaths for long periods at a time.

The blood and guts that seep from a speared fish attract sharks, which have a keen sense of smell.

A spear fisherman was killed by what was believed to be a huge tiger shark off South Africa in November 2003.

"Spear fishing can be dangerous. You learn not to keep your shot fish near you by sticking it on a long line," said Vic Cockcroft of South Africa's Center for Dolphin Studies.

South African waters have been the scene of a number of shark attacks recently, including one involving a surfer who survived a savaging late last month.

In March a British tourist had a narrow escape when a 5-meter (16.5-foot) great white tore into a diving cage about 100 km (60 miles) southeast of Cape Town. The attack was caught on video.

And an elderly woman was killed by a great white in November while she was having her daily swim near Cape Town.

"The incidents of shark presence seem to be much higher around the coasts (than they used to be) ... There is evidence that our waters are warming up because of climate change, but whether this is making them more productive or not we don't know," Cockcroft said.

The Florida-based International Shark Attack File says 61 shark attacks were reported in the world last year, slightly up on the 2003 total of 57. Seven of last year's attacks were fatal.
 
i've merged several threads on the subject and moved it here to Accidents
and Incidents.

apologies to all for any confusion
 
Justin699:
Sounds like its time for a shark derby! Mistaken identity my arse here. Seals don't shoot sharks with spearguns. Sounds like its also time for a spearfishing class with emphasis on aim.

What a strange reaction! The guy was spear fishing... a well known means of attracting sharks. Who's at fault here? The shark for being hungry and defending itself when attacked wit the spear gun?

While it is sad for the family and friends of the deceased and my condolences go out to them, can one not say fate was being tempted?
 
drbill:
What a strange reaction! The guy was spear fishing... a well known means of attracting sharks. Who's at fault here? The shark for being hungry and defending itself when attacked wit the spear gun?

While it is sad for the family and friends of the deceased and my condolences go out to them, can one not say fate was being tempted?


The story I read said they were attacked by the shark while spearfishing and tried to fight it off with their guns. I got the impression they shot the shark in self defense, NOT that they shot it before it attacked.

I'm all for conservation etc but I'd try to defend myself too if attacked.
 
humanFish:
I want to see the viedo mentioned in the article where the GWS tore into the diving cage. Has anyone seen it?

I've seen it, and was able to find a working link. Here ya go: Great White attacks cage

Enjoy it while you can, these don't usually last this long on news sites.
 
holy crap...

i'd never need laxatives again

(not that i need them now... it's, like, you know... a metaphor)
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/teric/

Back
Top Bottom