DevonDiver
N/A
It only seems silly from the comfort of the keyboard.
There's a huge difference between doing something in OW class and doing it in the middle of a stressful situation.
Absolutely correct.
If you plan your emergency contingencies for the best case scenario, then they will undoubtably fail when you need them, as reality will never be a best case scenario.
Never underestimate the impact of psychological stress on your ability to react to even a small emergency. Any planned contingency response, especially to an OOA scenario, needs to be simple, direct and fool-proof to the extreme. You need to estimate that you, or anyone else, will be operating on 25%, or less, of mental and physical capacity...and plan accordingly.
I've seen student divers freak (stress overload) because of a badly fitting mouthpiece. The same would be true for an experienced diver who was already suffering stress from an emergency. The same is true for tangled AAS hoses, tugged hoses etc.
Keep it fool-proof, because under stress we are all fools.