Respect is always assumed amongst freinds.
The physics of mathematics trumps subjective observation.
You are being fooled by an optical illusion.
"Sharpness"...meaning literaly the visual acuity? By sheer deffinition, what your mind is being tricked into believing is contrary to the math. When you reduce the quanity of light (and you do so with any tinting), what happens? Your iris opens up, and just as a camera lens, the focus becomes softer. Pure simple math. It can not be sharper. Like mom said... turn on a light, or you'll ruin your eyes. What that means is, using the most light possible, constrict your iris, see more clearly and sharply. Biology 101.
For years, we used high powered yellow beams on racing cars. It does increase the contrast, and in fog, distant penetration (with quantity of light) is never an issue- what you want to see is up close. The yellow helped to increase the contrast- that it surely does.
Contrarily, the quality of light is an absolute issue. We learned that severe spot lights triumphed over flood lights. We also found out that the closer you mounted them to the pavement, they penetrated farther as there was less fog withing 10" of the pavement. It also put the lighting on a different parallax angle than the drivers view (much like eliminating backscatter from u/w photo by remoting the strobes fronm the lens). Unfortunately, this has little to do with the use of tinted lenses in diving, but it does point up how distracting red herring arguments can be. Add in human perception over empiricaly tested reality. It's a hard sell.
Bottom line- if tinted yellow lenses were so good, why don't windshields come in yellow? We have the technology to electricaly alter glass shades on demand, but even on the most exotic cars, this isn't available. Hmmmm.
At 150-170, I would assume we're talking wrecks or fresh water- not much to see at that depth in the ocean for critters. Maybe, for a wreck diver, in the murk, looking at close up stuff and with plenty of lights- a good thing. For the other 99% of the diving public, useless.