I see your point. In our litigious society much that is excessive is normalized. As for me, at my age I no longer do any demanding advanced diving, so the issue is moot.But here's the problem. If you have all that experience and want to go on a more advanced dive, the dive operator's insurance still says you need to have a card. You can argue with all the accuracy in the world that your experience is better, but if it comes to a lawsuit, the dive operator still allowed a diver without the required qualifications to do the dive.
If you want a dive log with 200 dives in it to work instead, I can whip one up this afternoon.