Preferred BC's/Weighting

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

After about 15 dives on rental gear, I bought a SeaQuest Spectrum3 ADV jacket-style BC, and thought it was great until I started wanting something more durable (having less plastic and more stainless steel) that would continue to serve me well as I transition into more technical diving.

I found a great deal on a DiveRite Transpac II , and so far have been very happy with it. It's made it easier to adjust my trim, is less bulky and more versatile, and is more comfortable, more stable, and more streamlined than my old SQ. It also has removable wings, allowing me to adjust the bouyancy characteristics by selecting a wing with a size and profile suited to my needs. Currently, I dive with an AL80 tank and the Rec Wing, which provides up to 51 lbs of lift and can be used with a backplate and up to HP120 doubles if I so choose.

I expect that I'll eventually trade up to a bp/wing setup though, as it's the simplest, sturdiest, and most versatile way to go. I understand they're noticably more stable than even the transpac, and generally don't rely on any plastic connectors. As you go deeper or otherwise undertake more challenging dives, it becomes increasingly important to have gear you can rely on not to fail at an inopportune moment. If I had it to do over, I might have gone with this setup in the first place and spared myself the trouble of growing out of gear that worked, but which would soon seem inadequate to me.

As for bouyancy, I'm 5'11 and 240#, and started diving in a 2 piece 7mm wetsuit with 42 lbs, which was what it apparently took to drag my excited, figety, tense self to the bottom. I'm now diving with 28 lbs of lead, and could probably shave off another two and submerge just fine.

What made the difference? In a word, comfort. The more diving I did, the more relaxed I became, and the more I became aware of things like holding lots of air in my lungs at the surface, kicking my feet slightly while trying to submerge, etc. Next time you feel underweighted, try this:

Cross your legs as if sitting "Indian style" (so you don't accidentally kick). Relax, and hold your hands above your head while dumping all the air from your BC. Exhale deeply while staying relaxed, and see if you don't end up underwater. As you become more comfortable in the water, you can apply the same principles without the funny posture and achieve the same end.
 
Wow, I've really learned something. Based on all this feedback, I am coming around to believe that "it's not you, it's me..."

I am considering, given the reccommendations of a friend, investing in a Halcyon AL back plate and a pair of 30# (Oxycheq) wings. These would be used in New England waters with a 7mm WS and probably rented AL tanks for the time being.

I know ideally the back plate should be SS for diving in NE; I'm hoping it will be sufficiently verstaile to travel and be used in warmer waters as well. Does this sound like a reasonable approach to you seasoned denizens of the deep?

HOW ABOUT THOSE SOX????????????

(I didn't think the sinkerballer--named Lowe!--had it in him. Is this the year, or is the almightly just aligning the stars for the ultimate evisceration?) :boom: :confused: :) :confused:
 
I'd just go with the SS plate. In warm water, you'll likely be diving Al80s which are +4 at the end of a dive...The SS plate is -6 lbs, so you are really only dealing with -2 lbs of buoyancy at the end of a dive. A small weight belt and you're golden. In New England, it will put the weight where you want it....on your back, not your belt.
 
I would go with the steel plate if I were you. It'll move more weight from your belt to your back, and will still remain useful in warm water. With an aluminum tank and a steel plate you will likely still need some extra weight in warm water, though very little. With a steel plate and an AL tank in warm water, you will likely still need some weight, though perhaps very little. I'm 5'10", 175, and in a 3mm suit in warm water I'll take 4-5lbs if I'm diving an AL tank, and no weight belt at all with a steel one. Works great. The only time you'll need an AL plate is when you're very overweighted, if say you were diving steel doubles in a wet suit. My recommendation is go with the SS plate.

-Roman.
 
The same friend that recommended this system also suggested a V weight to provide more weight on my back. Any reaction to this possibiliy...as you can probably tell, I'm resisting the prospect of carrying an SS plate around in my luggage--wife plus two year old usually means I'm the beast of burden. What are the expereinces of people travelling with their equipment, including SS plates. Any prolonged hassles? Weight penalties? etc?

Again, thanks for all this feedback!
 
Since I started diving with a lower drag rig and good trim, my air consumption has gotten noticably better. The less you have to work, the longer you can stay down!
 
Hi, I am 5'11 and a fairly solid 245lbs. I dive with a Zeagle Tech and a 7 mil wetsuit when diving wet. With a steel 98 i use 20 lbs. I noticed the more i dive and the more comfortable i get the more the weight goes down. I dove with my dry suit for the first time this year this past weekend with a very bulky undergarment i borrowed and used 30 lbs.
 
and it is small enuf to travel with...

they don't make them anymore...the niterunner...but might have something comparable...
 

Back
Top Bottom