Panic

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Fish_Whisperer

Contributor
Messages
6,317
Reaction score
23
Location
In a car underwater with time to kill....
# of dives
50 - 99
The subject of panic was brought up in the thread on how divers' deaths affect us. I thought it worthy of starting a new thread so that it could be addressed.

What is the "cycle of panic," and what strategies are there to mitigate it, beyond the standard, "Stop, Breathe, Think"?

Thank you.
 
Fish_Whisperer:
The subject of panic was brought up in the thread on how divers' deaths affect us. I thought it worthy of starting a new thread so that it could be addressed.

What is the "cycle of panic," and what strategies are there to mitigate it, beyond the standard, "Stop, Breathe, Think"?

Thank you.

...definition, but in diving it refers to an irrational behavioural response to stress / stressors resulting in an inability to cope effectively. Left unaddressed, the behaviour may continue to deteriorate as the level of fear escalates, setting up a vicious cycle of fear begetting more fear, often with tragic result.

The absolute best cure? P-R-E-V-E-N-T-I-O-N-!!

> Always dive within YOUR personal capabilities & limitations - stay within your
personal comfort zone

> Know thine enemy - learn to recognize the rearing of it's ugly head - know how to
calm & control thyself out of danger

> If you buddy dive, well then BUDDY DIVE!! Take your personal responsibility for your
partner's safety seriously by staying within touching distance of them; anything less
is going it solo. You are a very effective stress management / de-stressing tool for
your partner

I will now leap graciously from my box of detergent...

Regards,
D.S.D.
 
DeepSeaDan:
> If you buddy dive, well then BUDDY DIVE!! Take your personal responsibility for your
partner's safety seriously by staying within touching distance of them; anything less
is going it solo. You are a very effective stress management / de-stressing tool for
your partner

I could not agree more ....... As inexperienced as I am, it makes me feel so much better when ther is a better qualified, more experienced diver within reach.

Great article by the way
.
 
A couple ideas:

First is better training so a person is more comfortable and therefore further from the panic threshold. But for better training there have to be better instructors. In my experience the curriculum doesn't determine quality instruction, the instructor does. All the curriculum does is provide a structure for the training sessions.

It really doesn't matter what field one is speaking of; it is very difficult to teach what a person doesn't know from personal experience. So instructors need to have more and wider variety experience, better understanding of teaching methods and be supported so that they don't take a financial hit for turning out qualified products. Under the current system the instructor maximizes income for themself and the LDS by processing many students and by being proficient at capturing that student as a customer of that LDS.

Next, the industry needs to stop taking refuge in the meaningless cover of the dive class graduate only being certified to dive in circumstances under which they were trained. On its' face that is true. But the effect for many graduates is to have adverse consequences. First, is reducing training to that specific locale only.

One result is a graduate that is not confident, is convinced the whole idea of more training is just an excuse to extract more money, etc. I suspect the drop out rate among divers, and the negative economic impact to the industry and all of us, from this attitude is significant.

It takes very little effort and cost to add knowledge and proficiency that will allow the graduate to better appreciate differences in dive requirements. Certainly there would be fewer beginning level dive graduates. But, they would be more confident, more knowledgable and more likely to pursue a long term dive hobby. That would have positive consequences for the industry and all of us.
 
Thanks Greg, there is some good information there, but it doesn't go far enough.

The first step in panic is feeling a lack of confidence in one's abilities.

An ability to swim fairly well is the first step toward confidence in the water. The next step is learning skin diving skills. A combination of swimming ability and mastering skin diving skills eliminates a feeling of being overly dependent on SCUBA equipment.

Skills left out of most classes (because some agencies don't include them in their standards) such as doff & don (removing all equipment on the pool bottom, swimming to the surface then returned to put it all back on) and bail out (stepping into the water while holding one's gear and putting it on during descent) also build self confidence and help to eliminate that first step toward panic.

The second step in panic is when something goes wrong. We can train and practice and maintain our equipment, but we can never eliminate problems arising. When things go wrong, a diver will either have confidence in their ability to handle the problem or they won't. If they do have confidence, they'll solve the problem and move on.

If they lack confidence, they will become scared and as a result start to hypoventilate. Hypoventilation is rapid shallow breathing. It is often, incorrectly, called uncontrolled hyperventilation. These are the next two steps in panic. Hypoventilation causes a buildup of CO2 in the lungs. This is because shallow breathing does not purge the lungs of CO2 on exhalation. As CO2 builds, the urge to breathe becomes even stronger. Hypoventilation increases, making the feeling of not being able to breathe even worse. This is what makes some divers think they are over breathing their regulator. Once hypoventilation starts, full panic is often seconds away. Once the diver is panicked, he will often take inappropriate and usually dangerous actions such as bolting to the surface.

An understanding of this cycle can allow a diver to break it and prevent panic. Most agencies teach divers, Stop, think, act. Some teach it as, Stop, breathe, think, act. This is wonderful, but it doesn't explain why and while the concept is a good one, a better understanding of the panic cycle is essential to breaking it. If a diver feels himself starting to hypoventilate, he needs to know this is an important step that can lead to his (and his buddy's) death if he doesn't take immediate action by slowing his breathing. Slow deep breaths are a life saver.
 
cardinal:
I could not agree more ....... As inexperienced as I am, it makes me feel so much better when ther is a better qualified, more experienced diver within reach.

Great article by the way
.

That's the first step to panic. Work on skills, get confidence in yourself. There's nothing anyone else can do that you can't learn as well.
 
Walter you keep addressing the specific skills and I'll keep at the system and we''ll do some good yet:D
 

Back
Top Bottom