- Messages
- 22,171
- Reaction score
- 2,790
- # of dives
- 5000 - ∞
22 - the logic of "not liberal enough" is reversed. 2:1 is TOO liberal. 1.6:1 is less liberal.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
22 - the logic of "not liberal enough" is reversed. 2:1 is TOO liberal. 1.6:1 is less liberal.
Maybe some divetable questions with 5 or 6 dives in a row :14:
Question 8: "Trimix consists of what?"
The question and answers are broken. If you want the right answer to be "2 Inert Gases and Oxygen" (by the way, spell out "two"), do not include the also-correct answer "Nitrogen, Helium, and Oxygen". There should only be one correct answer to each question, but this question has two correct answers. Additionally, if you accept any two inert gases in your definiton of trimix (as the answer key states), "Nitrogen, Argon, and Oxygen" would *also* count as a correct answer (although who would want to dive that? ).
I'm not a master diver, but I am a chemist. Yes, trimix is a mixture of three gasses. But if the answer is "two inert gases and oxygen", CHEMICALLY the answer "nitrogen, helium and oxygen" is not a correct answer. Nitrogen is not an inert gas (Group 18 on the periodic chart). Nitrogen, though not an oxidizer, is chemically active. The same logic goes for "nitrogen, argon, and oxygen". The only way the first answer could be correct would be if it were two truly inert gasses, for example, "argon, helium, and oxygen." Therefore, this question does not, in fact, have two correct answers (IF, as I understand, the answer should be "nitrogen, helium, and oxygen".)
I believe that in the context of the question, nitrogen is considered metabolically inert, which is true enough. I wasn't going to get into chemistry, as I know *far* too much to get started on that one.I'm not a master diver, but I am a chemist. Yes, trimix is a mixture of three gasses. But if the answer is "two inert gases and oxygen", CHEMICALLY the answer "nitrogen, helium and oxygen" is not a correct answer. Nitrogen is not an inert gas (Group 18 on the periodic chart). Nitrogen, though not an oxidizer, is chemically active. The same logic goes for "nitrogen, argon, and oxygen". The only way the first answer could be correct would be if it were two truly inert gasses, for example, "argon, helium, and oxygen." Therefore, this question does not, in fact, have two correct answers (IF, as I understand, the answer should be "nitrogen, helium, and oxygen".)