Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
If Your mushroom valve on your exhale side takes a dump then you’re rebreathing the gas with CO2 you just exhaled in addition to whatever gas comes down the inhale side from your BOV. The BOV in this case isn’t on the mouthpiece in the typical fashion meaning that when you bail out you’re going to the configuration of an old double hose reg, except instead of being behind your head it’s on your chest. The mushroom valves won’t be isolated like they are with a shrimp or dive soft.I'm not sure what a CO2 hit does to impact using the BOV. When you switch the BOV to OC, it closes off and seals the loop so any CO2 in there is out of the picture. The mushroom valves could have flown the coop entirely and the BOV in OC mode is going to work just fine.
That said, my Hollis BOV on my KISS has a piece of crap unbalanced 2nd stage. It's perfectly fine to quickly get off the loop. If I had to stay off the loop for an extended period, I would switch to my S600 strapped to the offboard dil/bailout.
I wonder if the smaller exhale lung, somehow helps reduce this risk. The BOV exhale gas has to vent externally somewhere right?If Your mushroom valve on your exhale side takes a dump then you’re rebreathing the gas with CO2 you just exhaled in addition to whatever gas comes down the inhale side from your BOV. The BOV in this case isn’t on the mouthpiece in the typical fashion meaning that when you bail out you’re going to the configuration of an old double hose reg, except instead of being behind your head it’s on your chest. The mushroom valves won’t be isolated like they are with a shrimp or dive soft.
Can you share the link? I can't find it.I did like Michael Menduno's review in InDepth, not afraid to bite the hand that feeds him.
Sneak Preview: Halcyon Symbios Chest Mount and KISS Sidewinder 2Can you share the link?
as aboveCan you share the link? I can't find it.
thanks
|
ETA: On second read, I noticed the mention of an oval axial scrubber. I find that interesting. My understanding is that the scrubber would be used up in a cylindrical area pushing out from the center, and that you can only use it as long as there is no path of exhausted scrubber for the gas to go through. It would seem that given those two things, the scrubber in the oval part of the canister would likely end up being consistently unused. I'm also aware that gas flow isn't exactly like laserbeams (or frictionless spheres... ) and that in practice it might not be as clear-cut. I certainly understand the value that reducing thickness has for any rebreather, but particularly for a chest-mounted one. I'm wondering what those of you with expertise might say about scrubber utilization in an oval canister?
Thus far most rebreathers have a cylindrical scrubber that is taller than the diameter. Flow is from bottom to top (a.k.a. Axial) or up a tube in the middle and through the scrubber to the outside (a.k.a. Radial, from the hub to the rim).On second read, I noticed the mention of an oval axial scrubber. I find that interesting. My understanding is that the scrubber would be used up in a cylindrical area pushing out from the center, and that you can only use it as long as there is no path of exhausted scrubber for the gas to go through. It would seem that given those two things, the scrubber in the oval part of the canister would likely end up being consistently unused.