Mesh backpack for carry-on?

[macado]

I know this is a common topic but I searched and didn't see too many opinions.

I'm specifically looking for a good mesh backpack that falls within TSA/Airline size restrictions. I see that the XS Scuba Compact Deluxe Bag has been mentioned in many threads.

Does such a bag exist and can anyone recommend a good mesh backpack?

I am looking for a small mesh backpack for carry-on that I can also use to transport my tropical gear to the boat. Normally, I just stuff my gear into a regular sized suitcase carry-on and hope for the best.

The XS Scuba Compact Deluxe Bag gets good reviews but it's length is 26" which is a bit longer than some of the size restrictions but I imagine since it's mesh it can be made a bit smaller? Has anyone successfully used this bag as a carry-on?

Thoughts/Opinions?

XS Scuba Compact Deluxe Mesh Backpack
XS Scuba BG323 Compact Deluxe Mesh Duffel Scuba Gear Bag

 

[slkay]

I use a stahlsac mesh backpack ( I think it is the Panama) as a carry on all the time when I take a dive vacation.

Fully packed it would be over the size limit for a carry on, so it really really depends on how much stuff you put in it. I usually put my mask, regulator, fins and wetsuit in it. I will then use a Akona roller for my BC, snorkel, second mesh bag and assorted other gear that I bring for my kids and wife (masks, fins, lights...).

My son uses a Dive Caddy and loves it, but we use the mesh bags once we are at our destination.

 

[Damselfish]

if you do this, just make sure there's no chance you will get forced to check it (due to size or full flight) as checking your gear in a mesh bag isn't too desirable.

 

[silvernotch]

I took our Akona mesh backpack through to Antigua and Montserrat last year with no issues. I had 2 sets of fins, masks, snorkels, and I think some other random gear in there.

 

[scubamarketing]

I just fold up a mesh bag (one of these: Akona Deluxe Mesh Backpack (AKB234)) and put it into one of my other bags. It packs really small and I can put it into a bag more specifically designed to maximize my carry-on usage (one of these, it's awesome: Amazon.com: 5.11 1 Day Rush Backpack: Sports & Outdoors). Best of both worlds, IMO.