My wife and I stayed at the Melia is Sept. through a RCI trade and loved the place. The food got a tad old after a while and due to the concrete monster (pier), the water was stained a few days but otherwise, it was a really nice place. I might also mention that by going thru RCI, we were treated very well, checked in in a small room off to the side (no waiting), and was given a room upon arrival (12:00 pm). We are heading back this summer and will probably stay there again.
As mentioned, the staff was great..the grounds were nice..the room was fine...and every now and then, the far end of the beach (north) hosted the topless crowd
. For clearer water, just walk over to the El Coz beach and swim there.
The taxi cost to calleta was $10 one way and there were always taxi's waiting in the morning. It takes about 15 mins in the morning and about 20-25 mins to get back.
Also, would like to recommend Alison (Scuba (or Dive, never remember) with Alison. Great lady, great DM, ,great all the way around!
We have some pics (never posted them) if you would like to check them out.