Jupiter31 -Just to clarify Ocean Divers -
They are not a "bad" operation; could not stay in business in the competitive upper Keys if they were.
However, they are a cattle boat OP and I MUCH prefer a smaller number of divers on the boat.
No worries, I never dove with them so I wouldn't be able to make that determination. I would agree they're doing something right to thrive in the Keys. I wouldn't ever say anyone was a bad op without personal experience.
I apologize if that's how anyone took it but just to clear the air -I certainly didn't think I said they were a bad op. It was just an observation that 3 or 4 dive shops out of all the dive shops in the Keys kept getting recommended.
Mostly for us it's not the size of the boat but rather the % of capacity they fill it, some 6 packs are cramped with 6 divers, some 40' boats are spacious with 20 divers, of course the number of divers in the water matters too - thus - like you I normally prefer the smaller boats. My wife prefers bigger boats because she sometimes gets motion sickness on the 6 packs.
Everyones entitled to their preference

Take care!