Hi
@Millemar
I have a few over 1300 dives in Boynton Beach, Jupiter, and Palm Beach since 2009. I use 5 of the same operators listed by
@Divin'Papaw Starfish and Loggerhead (Loggerhead is one of two boats with Splashdown) in Boynton Beach, Narcosis and Walker's in Palm Beach/Riviera Beach, and Jupiter Dive Center in Jupiter.
Neither Starfish nor Loggerhead put a guide in the water. Narcosis, Walker's, and Jupiter Dive Center put a guide in the water. You can stay with and surface with the guides or surface on your own DSMB.
All my family's regulators are Scubapro, I have them serviced at Jupiter Dive Center.
Best of luck with your diving in Florida. I think you will find the diving to be competitive with or better than many Caribbean sites. The three locations mentioned are somewhat different and quite complimentary, try them all.