I only posted it for fullness of discussion as many people do find it to be a very good option. I have caveated that a number of time to the extent that
@Happyladydiver is the only person that knows what will be right for her so try options and make an informed decision.
I agree with you on that - you have asked the question and most people here will try to give you unbiased advice. A good shop should ask you almost as many questions as you ask them to determine that the items are right for you.
Certain circles of divers (particularly on Scubaboard where there can be a bit of a tech diving bias) believe BP&W is the only option but it doesn't suit everyone and I am happy to admit that.