The others are preferred as that is what one can stock in a shop and fit everybody that walks in.I never had anything else than neoprene, so I can’t compare.
Neoprene looks sturdy to me.
Is there a reason to prefer the other ones?
Neoprene necks are custom fit to the customer, it adds cost therefore shops will typically talk someone out of them.
With a roll under style neoprene, it should fit your neck perfectly with no slop before folding in. That makes it about 6-10mm smaller than your neck when folded properly.
They are easy to re-size, slice it longways about 3". Remove about 1/8" material, glue the edges back together with neoprene cement. That is all Santi will do when you send it back for adjustment.