robbcayman:
Thanks for all the suggestions. I especially like the Virgin Islands & St.Lucia. For some reason my wife to be is hell bent on staying at a Sandals & there are a few on St. Lucia. Has anyone had an experience with the Sandals hotel chain? Are they the Wal-Mart of the Caribbean etc..?
I have stayed at all three Sandals on St. Lucia. One of them, the Grande St. Lucian was a Radisson property when we stayed there -- and this one is my wife's favorite.
Each of the three has a little something different to offer. Of course, any all-inclusive package scheme has some procedures to deal with, overall the staffs are focused on the guests enjoying themselves.
Now for scuba diving. Sandals resorts offer one-tank dives only. There is a morning and an afternoon dive. For certified divers, they very often require a check-out session in the pool. This can mean that you won't dive until your third day. If you have recently dived, and you're not a jerk, they
might let bypass the checkout pool session.
The dive day procedure in St Lucia is to meet at the watersports office, then take a bus to Castries harbor, get your gear at the harbor, then get on the boat. This takes a chunk of time, and can get old as you do multiple dives.
The Grande St. Lucian had a terrific dive center when we stayed there (as a Radisson). If Sandals kept this dive center open, it would be a lot more convenient because the dive boats depart right from the property.
The dive sites closest to the Sandals properties were "just OK" in my opinion. However, they took us to Anse Chastanet and Souffrie about 3 out of 4 dives, and the diving is beautiful. The reefs are healthy and drift dives are fun. Some people are unimpressed with the diving because it isn't on par with the best dive sites in the world. You need to judge this for yourself.
Lastly, if your style doesn't fit the all-inclusive stuff, I second Tim Ingersoll recommendation to stay at Anse Chastanet!
Congratulations,
Carbon