Happy to be alive - scuba diving incident in Brockville, Ontario

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

sarora

Guest
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Location
Toronto, Canada
I got PADI open water scuba diver certification in August, 2004 in Bala, Ontario. After getting certified, I decided to do my first recreational dive trip in Brockville last weekend (Sep. 11/12, 2004). The trip consisted of four wreck dives in Brockville, Ontario (Henry C. Daryaw, Lillie Parsons, Muscallonge and Robert Gaskin). I just picked Brockville just because the weekend was suitable for my schedule. I didn't know anything about the type of dives and conditions of dives. On Saturday, I dived Henry C. Daryaw (87ft.) and Lillie Parsons (60ft.). The current was strong in the first dive and I was running low on air. On ascent, I had to buddy breath with the dive instructor. But it was all fine. I really enjoyed the second dive - and it was my favourite.

The next day, I descended down the rope (current) at Muscallonge dive site with the initial air of 2800 psi and at 80ft once I got down, I was down to 1700 psi. At this point, I realized that I am using a lot of air. We were told that if we were close to 1500 psi, we should tell the dive master and should slowly start making my way up. At 1500 psi, I was able to tell my air count to the dive master. He asked me to follow him. My buddy was right besides me. I realized that I was sinking and had too much weight on me. I had to put more air in BCD. A thought went into my mind that I cannot inflate my BCD because I will end up using a lot more air. I went around the wreck trying to find the line (the line was no where to be seen). Then all of a sudden, I started hyperventilating. I felt suffocation. I thought I couldn't breathe. I realized that my breath was very shallow and fast, but I couldn't make it stop. I got a panic attack!

Next thing I know I am looking up, disregarding any signals from my buddy and making my way to the surface. The buddy followed me. I have never felt like that in my entire life. I have never ever had a panic attack. So I don't even know what I was going through. But one thing for sure, all the training that I went through was no where in my mind. I was just looking to get to the surface. I started going up from 75ft up very fast (not the usual 1foot/second) without any safety stop. I wasn't even thinking of stopping. I still had regulator in my mouth with a lot of shallow breathing. I was looking up and thus couldn't really see what my buddy was trying to tell me. I thought that I was dying. I kept going up and I saw the light. At this point I don't remember what happened. The next thing I noticed was my BCD getting a lot of air in it. My buddy had inflated my BCD. I immediately removed the reg from my mouth and that followed with a vomit. I looked around and saw my buddy trying to take me to a line that was thrown by another boat (not our boat). But the current was so strong that both of us were not going near it. I knew at this point what was going on - there were at least three boats around us but about 40-50 ft away. One of the divers from the nearest boat jumped in the water and brought the rope to us. We used the rope to get back to the boat. They took both of us to our boat where I was supposed to get some oxygen but the boat didn't have any. The boat then took us to the shore, where I got oxygen immediately. The were asking me a lot of questions. They then took me to the hospital, where I got more oxygen and had to get chest x-rays done. I was feeling alright (phsycially but not psychologically) - and this whole ordeal about hospital scared me more than anything. I thought that something was wrong with me. The x-rays were fine (they were looking for water in my lungs) but the doctor said that if I see any symptoms of the bends, I should go to the hospital immediately. This is my second day since the incident and so far I feel fine physically.

This incident has given me a very different perspective on life. I feel happy to be alive and to be able to share this story with others, angry for getting the panic attack, guilty for also involving my buddy in it and letting him go through this ugly experience .... and there are a lot of other mixed emotions I have. I am still trying to recover, but I know for sure that I need to do the same dive again to get some closure. I should be calm and relaxed and deal with the shortness of breath under water. I know now that CO2 was built up because of shallow breathing - during the incident I had no clue that it was CO2. I just needed to take a deep breath. I love exploring and there is a whole new world under water. I would like this incident to not stop me for pursuing my interest and I am going to try my best to overcome any fear that triggered this panic attack.

All the people that love me have been angry at me for playing with my life. They talked to some of their diver friends and they are saying that I shouldn't have gone that deep as a beginner diver. They are wondering that why didn't the instructor/dive masters alert me about this. I told them that it is my responsibility and I should have been more aware. Besides, even if they had alerted me, I would have still gone given my adventurous spirit. I was ignorant, but I urge all you beginner divers out there to be more aware and diligent than me. Also, another lesson I learnt from this is to never go diving alone. I am a fairly independent person in life who wants to do everything herself without asking for any help. I was assigned a buddy and sometimes we develop hesitation in showing our weaknesses to our buddy. If I am able to trust someone down there, I believe I would have been more calm and relaxed.

Please take good care of yourself, be safe and enjoy every second of your life! May God bless you!
 
Man, I'm happy that you are alive, but also upset that you pushed limits outside of your experience and thus endangering you and your buddies lives. Please dive safe, you can go deep later, get the experience first. Welcome to the board, good place to learn from other peoples mistakes.
 
I'm thankful that you are alright.

It's important to work on your breathing control before you dive past 60 feet. It's not at all uncommon for a new diver to have less than 2000 psi when they reach depth.

Those dives were beyond your current comfort level, and that's why you panicked. It's damn right scary to be a depth and think, "I'm running out of air"

Once your breathing is better, that dive will be much easier. Just take it slow and enjoy yourself, and learn from this.

You were fine at 60 feet, and low on air at 80 during your first two dives. You know you probably shouldn't have done the third dive at 80 feet yet.

The good thing is, you seem to be ok.

Good luck to you.

Xanthro
 
I dived some of those wrecks a couple of weeks ago. I would not suggest them to a first trip newbie without a personal DM. Significant currents - isn't the Lilly Parons the one with the wild current? Limited viz, overhead freighters in some areas. Bad place to work on the new diver basics. Oh - and I used 120 cf tanks, to be sure I wouldn't get in your position, plus the 19 cf pony - just in case.

Talk to your local friends on the Ontario club forum, complete your Profile & Dive Info, and look into getting a lot of practice on eaiser dives. Go back to Brockville next year with your AOW.
 
All I had to read were the words "certified August 2004,", "first recreational dive trip" and "wreck dive" to realize that something bad was going to happen.

I believe that each diver is ultimately responsible for his/her own safety, but the date on your c-card should have been a clue to that boat crew that they should have a further chat with you about your dive experience and especially the dive conditions that were expected. Assuming they even LOOKED at your c-card and noted the date, for them to think you were even remotely experienced enough to do this dive was preposterous.

I'm glad that you lived to tell about your experience. Do yourself a favor though and stick to simple, shallow dives for right now. Those wrecks aren't going anywhere. If you really want to dive those wrecks again slowly increase the depths and complexity until you feel you are capable of handling those conditions again.
 
Fisrt, welcome to the board.

Second, it looks like you learned a very valuable lesson, too bad it had to be the hard way but glad everything is OK and you're here to share it with us.

It's obvious that you bit off more than you could chew by doing these dives and yes,.....you are ultimately responsible. If the dive op knew about your experience level, and were diligent, they might have suggested that you not do these dives. It's always advisable to be totally honest with yourself and the dive operator about your experience. You didn't mention if the dive op asked you any questions about your experience while you were booking or if you even inquired about the experience level required for these dives. What did you talk about on the boat before the dive, did the DM even ask you any questions about your diving experience?

I'll state the obvious, start out with some shallow dives until you gain experience and don't be over confident with yourself. I wouldn't recommend doing those dives again until then, don't push it, you might not be so lucky next time.
 
Welcome to ScubaBoard and thank you for posting this.
Glad you're OK!!
sarora:
...but I know for sure that I need to do the same dive again to get some closure. I should be calm and relaxed and deal with the shortness of breath under water...
I gotta disagree here. Like others have already said, you need to be comfortable diving in shallow water before you do this dive again. May I make a suggestion? Find an experienced and competant mentor who is willing to spend time with you on easy dives. Work on your weighting, trim and buoyancy control (including breath control) while just relaxing in water less than about 30' deep. As you gain competance, you will gain comfort and confidence in the water.
 
getwet2 brings up an important point: if you are going on a dive that you've never done before, ALWAYS ask someone from the boat crew what the conditions are expected to be and inform them of your experience (or lack thereof).

I recently turned down a dive operator in Monterey because I felt I wasn't getting the answers I was looking for. The person on the phone seemed more interested in getting my credit card number than answering questions about depth, currents, etc. Things that are important to any diver, but especially important to a newbie.
 
I would agree with those who have said to give it some time & some dives before you dive there again. My OH CRAP! dive was over 60 dives and one year ago, and I feel like I could safely do that dive now, but I am waiting till I KNOW that it will be a breeze.

Take your time, spend some time doing shallower dives with experienced buddies (BTW, that can be the hardest part, finding GOOD buddies). That wreck will still be there when you are ready.
 
Sarora,
Ditto what everyone said. Definitely glad you're ok.

Another lesson in all of this is to ask what kind of dives you're signing up for. The charter captain should be able to provide that information to you if you advise him/her of your experience level. Or post in the Ontario Fresh Water Freaks section: there are lots of divers there who can give you a good idea of what to expect. In fact, I know there'll be instructors and very experienced divers at OFWF who would be happy to make the next dive with you to ensure you have a great time! :)

Brockville is fantastic diving, and I really hope you will return. And there's no reason to postpone it either: sign up for AOW, and you'll be diving with the assurance of having an instructor (a good one of course; i.e. one you feel safe with) with you; or go with an experienced diver who is willing and able to mentor you through it. It would go a long way towards undoing some of the nasty feelings you got from this experience. Dive again as soon as you feel you can manage it...these feelings sometimes have a way of festering.
 

Back
Top Bottom