dflaher...I think I was on the that dive boat with you at Snapper Hole (Thursday). Although I'm not sure which one on the boat you were.
My report is below...
We stayed at The Reef Resort and Dove with Ocean Frontiers from 7/3 to 7/10. I will have to say it was an amazing dive vacation.
We stayed at the northern most Reef Resort building which we were told was 4 years old (with the main building being 10 years old). The hotel was immaculate...all rooms have a view of the ocean with a huge sliding glass doors for a great view. The grout in the tiles was clean and the rooms had high ceilings which made it feel more spacious. The oustside deck was spacious. Everything was clean and perfect...our room had high ceilings too. There is a liquor store, Dunkin Donuts, and grocery store across the street. The prices were a little bit more than the US, but not bad at all. They had about everything you needed from meats, snacks, fruits, milk/juices, etc. We ate a couple of times at the resort and the food was very good. Did I mention the studio rooms are on special for $99 a night? That's a great deal!
Oh and for people that can't just sit on the beach and do nothing, the reef offers excellent snorkeling in 3-5 ft of water. Right in front of the hotel, I found two porcupine puffers, several lobster, a 4 ft barracuda, needle fish, stingrays, mantis shrimp, small crabs, serpent starts, anenomes, and lots of juvenile and adult reef fish. There's a lot to see and I suggest bringing some dive gloves for the snorkeling...but not the diving! I snorkelled for hours each day and never got bored because there was always something new to find.
We ate a couple times in Georgetown....but most of our meals were groceries in the morning and during the day but a more pricey meal at night. We ate at Over the Edge (on the north side of the island) a couple of times. I recommend the Wahoo....its kind of expensive but not crazy...a meal for two was $60 or so. We ate at the Lighthouse for our final meal and that place is pricey. One drink, an appetizer, our main course and a dessert with tip was $110....that should put it in perspective.
As far as diving with Ocean Frontiers...what a top notch operation (like everyone said). Everyone on the crew (15-20 people) were very personable and truly wanted your dive experience to be a great one. They would guide you if you wanted but as you were around a couple of days would allow you to explore on your own if you so desired. We seemed to miss alot on our one exploration dives though so it might be best do go with the guide if you don't want to miss the cool stuff. Elly does a great job with photography and videos during the dive so make sure to look her up! My favorite dive was Snapper Hole due to the awesome silverside filled swim throughs with huge tarpon. The reef on top was amazing too as you could peer down at the deep holes of silversides leading back into the swim throughs. Elly was there to capture it all ! Thanks Ocean Frontiers for a great dive trip!
I highly recommend this vacation...its was the best dive vacation I've ever had. Make sure to rent a car so you and explore the island.