Yeah, I will admit that I initially made students suffer a bit with doing the weighting procedure that I was taught in my IDC (which sadly was about 5 lbs overweight, as the negative buoyancy of the scuba kit wasn't factored in).We were in 7 mil farmer john wetsuits. Appreciate the process described. Have read of a variation or two of it.
Still to date always diving wet, the 4 years I assisted on OW courses weight checks were done at the ocean at the start of OW dive 1. But, I only assisted in Aug.-Oct. when cold water was no issue. I did assist once in Nov. as a DMC and can't recall if checks were done. Either way, I would be surprised to see a shop follow this procedure for each student--you know, the old "time constraints".
I have heard the shop has begun a bit of offering the OW course in drysuits. Don't know how that is decided/rented, etc.
The method I described was influenced by @custureri who had a blog post on it (Proper Weighting Procedure for Divers). My method isn't perfect, but it got pretty darn close, and any adjustment on the first OW dive was confirmed on the second one. When I open up shop in Greece, I will be using that method again. I will have a database of each wetsuit and its positive buoyancy characteristics, as well as the negative characteristics of the scuba kit. Fins will be Deep 6 Eddy fins that are neutral.
To me, being a cold water dive instructor, I have to manage my student's comfort (I know I am preaching to the choir). That's why I don't teach in wetsuits here, and I also teach only 2 students at a time, as I want them to be moving more (though sometimes just getting used to being as still as possible). I do have concern about students getting cold in dry suits. I want to make dives as long as possible, but as long as my students are comfortable, as being cold is not conducive to learning. I'd rather do just one dive a day if necessary and have the course drag out, or a big surface interval. I'll be flexible to whatever works for my students. As an independent I can do that.
But getting to the OP. I think classes are rushed. Students learn to dive in CW. If using a warm pool for CW and OW is in cold water, I think a dive for acclimation is appropriate to ensure students are relaxed. I do believe time spent on getting students relaxed pays off. Just as getting them neutrally buoyant/trim, as instructors far more experienced/skilled than me have proven to streamline the time required to develop proficiency at all the skills. Student comfort in terms of temperature, floating in the water column are paramount. I'm a big believer in addressing all of that at the start of the course.
Students with check-box instructors are likely to not exhale as much, and thus require more weight than what they would need while relaxed.