Embarrassment at Little Farnsworth

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

drbill

The Lorax for the Kelp Forest
Scuba Legend
Rest in Peace
Messages
22,824
Reaction score
6,066
Location
Santa Catalina Island, CA
# of dives
2500 - 4999
As some of you know, I've been SCUBA diving for 45 years now with experience in a wide range of locations around the globe. I feel I am a pretty good diver, although not yet a great technical one (since my focus is on my biological research and film making).

Although not a "proud" person by nature, yesterday I was humbled a bit on my second dive. Our first dive had been at Farnsworth Bank, a blue water dive about 2-3 miles off the windward side of Catalina Island. Although there was current and a good NW swell, that dive went off without a hitch and I dropped to 146 ft and up to 100 ft to film the purple hydrocoral (which was my goal on that dive) on one of the high points. My buddy, diving Nitrox, remained above me throughout the dive.

The captain decided to relocate for the second dive due in part to the current and swell, but mostly due to poor upper water column visibility (it was a max of 50 ft at depth). We motored to the front side to dive Little Farnsworth. Great, I was looking forward to this combination of dives.

Prior to entering the water at L.F., we were told there was a good current running. I've dived strong currents before so this was not a concern. However, after I entered the water off the swim step, I had great difficulty getting to the anchor line at the bow. I should have aborted the dive at that point, but really wanted to dive this site.

I descended with two buddies just below me. The vis was very poor so I kept an eye on their bubbles and the anchor line (which I never reached). Suddenly their bubbles disappeared behind me. I looked ahead and the anchor line had also disappeared from site. I had reached 86 ft without hitting the bottom of the pinnacle, so I decided to surface slowly (not as slow as I desired though).

When I finally reached the surface after 9 min, I was 300 ft from the stern and drifting fast. There was no way I could make progress against the current with my kit (pony affected my streamlining), camcorder housing in hand and my split fins. I ate my pride and yelled for assistance. Dive master/instructor (and occasional buddy) Tim paddled out on a kayak with the current line.

I was pretty tired from fighting the current and even though Tim took my camera, I wasn't making much progress on the line (hands slipping due to current). I finally held on and had the crew pull me in. I was mortified. I've only required assistance twice in my diving career, both times due to strong currents. Once back on the swim step and after catching my breath, my two buddies surfaced 2-3X as far away and had to be assisted. A fourth diver ended up going to the chamber for assessment.

My point? If you feel the dive is questionable (as I did at the surface heading towards the bow and anchor line), give serious thought to calling it before a situation develops. There were at least 5-6 divers on board who decided not to even suit up for this dive. Perhaps they were the smartest ones. Even the two tech divers from the crew had trouble crawling along the bottom to find the anchor.

Although the current and very poor vis were the primary factors involved here, there was another thought going through my mind. About two years ago friends of mine were passing this site and observed a great white hit, and totally disembowel, a large sea lion at the surface. I didn't like being hanging bait!
 
Great points, nothing to be embarrased about, some form of this happens to all of us. Without a doubt you have to say the 5-6 that did not suit up made the right choice. Thanks for posting this.
 
Good post, Bill. Thank you! These are the kinds of stories that all can learn good lessons from, although a lot of us have "been there" as well. Glad it all came out right in the end. Sort of a true life version of: "What does not kill us makes us stronger!" (Think heavy Austrian accent here!) :D
 
drbill:
I should have aborted the dive at that point, but really wanted to dive this site.
This is the sentance we always see, and yet, I wonder if we really get the point of Bill's post. I say I do, but I wonder...

Thanks, Bill!
 
Bill

I have some experience with Channel Island currents also. One occasion last year I had to use the kelp as a current line to keep from being swept away on a dive off San Clemente. What makes your current so tricky is it is not predictable. It varies greatly even during a single dive as you change depths or even just swim around a corner. Its not like drift diving where everybody is expecting and planning for a current. Were you on the King Neptune? The times I have dove with them they manage to find relatively calm sites.
 
My point? If you feel the dive is questionable (as I did at the surface heading towards the bow and anchor line), give serious thought to calling it before a situation develops.

I also had to learn this one the hard way.

Glad you are OK.

-V
 
drbill

The main lesson that I take from your post is that no matter how much experience a person has, they can still learn.

I will bet that there are many of us with much less experience, but a similar story, who would not find the time to post to SB about an incident like this.

Thanks.
 
drbill: Thanks for such a good honest post. Had a similar experience while diving in blue water off the Bahama Islands while I was a dive rep for SeaQuest. Took a nice compass course and headed up current, turned around 1/3 into the dive and then surfaced for a bearing, I was dead astern of the boat, the compass heading was right, problem was I was in a ripping gulfstream current and on my way back to Miami. I took another bearing and went deeper figuring I could make more progress than on the surface. I was wearing a pair of Mares Power Plana fins, lots of torgue with a good wide kick, no help, @ 500 PSI I surfaced again, I had made very little progress. At that point I fully inflated my BC and waved for help. The boat launced a Zodiac and I was back aboard much to my chagrin and the amusement of the entire Seaquest family. Glad you are back safe.
 
Brian Gilpin:
Bill

I have some experience with Channel Island currents also. One occasion last year I had to use the kelp as a current line to keep from being swept away on a dive off San Clemente. What makes your current so tricky is it is not predictable. It varies greatly even during a single dive as you change depths or even just swim around a corner. Its not like drift diving where everybody is expecting and planning for a current. Were you on the King Neptune? The times I have dove with them they manage to find relatively calm sites.

Yes, I was on the King Neptune but no fault should go their way. It was not at all evident that the current was that bad until I got in. They are a great operation and I dive with them quite often (the DM who assisted me is an occasional buddy).

I remember one dive at Casino Point last summer. I headed into a stiff current going towards the wreck of the Sujac (harbor mouth) and fought it all the way to the wreck, dove to the base and by the time I returned to 60 ft where I planned my return, the current had completely reversed 180 degrees and was just as strong. Just goes to show you can walk to school uphill both ways! Of course the finger reefs at that site break things up nicely and offer plenty of protection.
 
Dr Bill, I did not notice you were embarrased about being pulled back to the boat. I thought quite highly of you when you readily admited that to me as we watched the other two slowly make their way back. It was a pleasure meeting you, and I meant to ask Chris when I talked to him today if I get a voucher for the dives or should I just consider myself lucky that I only to a ride TO the chamber and not IN it.
 

Back
Top Bottom