Rather than starting a new thread I thought I'd tack onto the end of this one since we'll be in Maui in March as well and could use some advice.
We're a newly-certified scuba family: my two sons are 14&16 and my wife and I are, um, more 'mature'. We all just did our OW at the beginning of this month in Cozumel and have logged less than 10 dives. We're looking to do a few days of diving while we're in Maui for the kids' March school break. From reading the posts in this section, I think I've got a pretty good idea of what people think of the various dive operations in the area. Lots of great info - thanks!
We're staying near Lahaina from the 9th to the 16th. Right now we're planning on doing about 3 or 4 mornings of diving and going with a couple of different operators (B&B, Extended Horizons?) Would we be best renting equipment from a shop in town for the whole time we're there or from the operator we're with for the day? We've only got our own snorkel gear: fins, masks, boots, snorkels. If you think a shop in town is best, any recommendations?
Any other advice you can give to a bunch of real newbies would be appreciated!