Wildcard:
http://www.scubaboard.com/showthread.php?t=164365
The opinion of two local instructors vs one baby diver from the mainland. Take your pick!
Hey Wildcard -
You're certainly entitled to your opinion (you know what they say, everyone has one...) but I have to ask you, have you actually dove with Fathom Five anytime recently?
Your beef seems to be the price you were quoted for a tank fill and opinions based on experiences with them some time ago.
Okay, I'm from the mainland (now, though seven years North Shore O'ahu) but I'm no baby diver. And based on four boat dives with Fathom Five this week, two different DMs, two different captains, I can say that in
my opinion, they are a good outfit. Well organized, helpful without being baby sitters, responsive, small groups (four divers each time,) professionally run. I appreciated the fact that the DM was there for those who wanted or needed them, but not in our faces since we didn't.
The diving is what it is, and this hasn't been a great week to dive with a big swell from the South, but that's the same set of conditions any dive op would face. I would definitely dive with them again. Are some local politics or some kama aina thing underneath this?
I like reading your posts about Hawaii diving, you never pull punches, but on this one, aside from your statements about pricing for a tank rental, your bashing of Fathom Five does not square at all with my very recent experiences with them. I recommend that those going to Kau'ai seriously consider diving with Fathom Five (and by the way, a pretty respected and brutally honest local guidebook - "The Ultimate Kau'ai Guidebook" in its 2007 edition - agrees, making Fathom Five their #1 recommended dive company.)