The Tahoe reports are published. If you have questions I'd suggest you download the .pdf and read them.
I have *zero* desire to have this thread devolve into a pissing match about different brands of scooters.
You're the one who started the pissing match about different brands of scooters. I never mentioned the brand of scooter I own in this thread. That's not what it ever was about. You're the one who dragged that into this thread.
I'll point out it was *YOU* that made the claim that operating a scooter at 250 ft / min was "relaxing" I know *nobody* else that would agree. 200 ft / min is pretty easy. The scooters I dive routinely are 200 ft / min in first gear....... 250 ft / min is a whole different story. Maybe only real studs find 250 ft / min relaxing.
Go back and read my post. I stated 200-250 fpm range. I never said I was running it at 250. And yes, it is relaxing. And I know other divers that do the same and agree. So just because YOU know *nobody* else that would agree doesn't mean it's the end all. I'm no stud. Far from it. Don't try to imply that I'M the one with an ego here.
Now you you have walked that back to 245 ft min.
Again, I gave a range. 245 fpm is within the range I initially gave.
That's still faster than the Magnus was shown to be at Tahoe. Is sidemount scootering faster than backmount? I happen to have tested both, and much to my surprise sidemount was slower. Now I'll be the first to admit I have limited time in side mount compared to Backmount, but.....
My side mount config was pretty slippery. 3mm wetsuit + two al 80's. I expected to be faster in sidemount. I wasn't. I was slower. I didn't have a stage or deco bottle either.
Do you have any reliable, repeatable, scooter speed trials to support your claim that sidemount scooter is faster? Please don't waste my time with anecdotal reports. Real, repeatable, data.
I have no interest in trying to prove anything. Since you apparently do, maybe you should arrange to have these trials done at the next Tahoe Benchmark. My recommendation would be to get sidemount divers who are experienced in sidemount, though, not just backmount divers in sidemount configuration.
Bottom line for this thread; the claimed speeds of 160 meters / min are a fantasy IMO.
Wow! We actually agree on something!!