Diver accident in Michigan

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

bobmaggi:
I wanted to get this out myself before it gets picked up and the facts distorted.

My wife and myselft were together diving the wreck of the Cedarville in the Mackinac Straits in Michigan this last Saturday. She is OW, AOW and Nitrox certified, diving just over 2 years, with 94 dives experience. I am certified up through Trimix, have over 450 dives experience. We were both in dry suits and expecting a bottom temp of 42 degrees and NDL dive time of around 20-25 minutes.
There were six divers on the boat, we were the second team to enter the water. The dive master was in the first group.
All went as expected, there was a light current heading away from the boat, the water temp was warmer than expected, 50 degrees, and visibility was 30-40 feet. I was taking photos and she was staying within 4 feet of me at all times. At 9 minutes into the dive I snapped a photo and saw some movement out of the corner of my eye. She had dropped her regulator and was picking it up and placing it back into her mouth OK. This normally no big deal, but this time she spit the reg out right away and started choking, panicing and started trying to swim up.
I grabbed her reg and tried to put it back in her mouth but at this point she was panicing and fighting me. I lost hold of her reg so I then grabbed my reg and tried to put it in her mouth with the purge depressed and switched to my bungied backup reg. I held on to her and started swimming up from 73 feet.
Unfortunately I couldn't control the ascent very well with holding on to her and the trying to keep the reg in her mouth so I wasn't able to dump air as we came up. So we shot to the surface in about 30 seconds based on dive computer having a 30 second logging interval.
She stopped fighting me and went limp before we reached the surface and was vomiting and not breathing.
On the surface I towed her about 200 feet to the boat. We had been the second group of divers so only the captain was on-board at this time. While the captain held her head out of the water I got out of my gear and then ditched her gear and pulled her into the boat. She had a faint pulse so I did artifical respiration and chest compressions to try to clear some of the water she inhaled.
The dive master was in the first group and coming up she saw her gear floating away so she retrieved it but didn't know what was happened until she got on-board. She also works in the medical profession so she started cutting her out of the dry suit while I kept breathing for her. After a while she would start to take an occassional breath on her own and finally was breathing unassisted.
The last group in the water knew something was wrong when they spotted my camera on the bottom. They retrieved it and then they heard the banging on the hull and so aborted the dive.
We docked in Mackinac City where the Coast Guard and ambulance showed up. We took her to Cheboygan where they stabilized her. The decision was made to take her to Marquette since that is where the closest chamber was. They couldn't fly because of bad weather so she went by ambulance. We drove the 180 miles to Marquette General Hospital.
At the hospital they monitored her for an embolism and both of us for the bends. She did a 2.5 hour chamber ride Saturday night. So far I haven't shown any sign of the bends so I hope that means she is in the clear also.
Right now she is heavily sedated in the ICU with no damage showing on the x-rays or CAT scan. There is some lung damage so she remains on a ventilator but they are slowly reducing the oxygen levels while monitoring her blood oxygen levels.
The best we can determine is that she inhaled without purging the reg so aspirated lake water which started a choking/coughing fit which would lead to more water being aspirated. This may also be the reason she doesn't appear to have and embolism because she kept her airway open from the coughing. The short time period down (9-10 min), it being the first dive of the day probobly saved us from the bends although I'm sure my blood was fizzing pretty good.
What else could I have done? Once on the surface I inflated her BC and my wing but didn't dump any weights however she was floating fairly well out of the water and I was able to keep her head up.
Next, I didn't give her any rescue breaths on the tow to the boat; we tried to pull her aboard at first with all her gear on. It wasn't until I removed my gear and was able to get up on the swim platform that I first thought about getting the gear off.
Once on the boat we really needed sissors to cut the dry suit off, we were able to use a knife to cut the neck seal but sissors are quicker and safer for the diver and person using the knife in this type of a panic situation. Luckily one of the other divers had shears that openned up the suit quickly. The divemaster helped with removing the suit, encouraging me and letting me know I was doing the right thing which was a big itme in my mind - I was just hoping that I wasn't forgetting anything else I could due to help.
The dive boat either didn't have oxygen or no one could find it. Luckily there was a stage bottle of 50/50 with a reg on it that we were able to hold the purge button over her mouth once she started breathing on her own.
I'm sure others will find other mistakes but the important thing is that she is breathing and her prognosis is good for this stage. That CPR/AED and First Aid class I took last year come in very handy, I'm definately going back and taking the Rescue Diver class the next time it is offered!
Sorry this has gotten probobly too long but I wanted to ensure the facts as witnessed by someone who was directly involved got out before any speculation started.
Bob
i'm glad that you and your wife are as good as can be expected. it could have been much worse..there is something to be said about training.....in a panic situation the only this that truly kicks in is training and experience. you did everything right. and, your wife is alive because of it!!! my hat is off to you!!!!!!!! god be with you and your wife, ken
 
I am glad that your quick thinking led to your level headed rescue of your wife. You definitely should take the rescue diver course. I am taking it currently. I have learned so much already. I can't believe that I completed as many dives as I did without the rescue diver knowledge. Hopefully you and your wife will have many years of diving together. You are obviously a good buddy to have. I would dive with you any day. She is lucky to have you. I pray that she will not suffer any lasting effects of this really bad day. My heart goes out to you both!
Coconut Girl
 
Bob,

Your wife is in my prayers. I hope for a complete recovery for her, and a healing from the trauma for both of you.

You did everything that was necessary.

I suspect that in the future you may carry some items with you on dive trips that you did not have this trip. But I think you can stop second-guessing yourself now. Given what you had to work with, you did a fine job.

Please tell your wife that many divers she does not even know are praying for her recovery tonight.

Doc
 
I, too pray for your wife and send congratulations to you. You did your best, and did, as far as I can see, enough to get the job done.

One thing I think I would have done differently (remember, I'm a pro, and my wife wasn't involved.....things get muddy when it's family...) from what you said, her being on the surface and not breathing, I certainly would have been giving her rescue breaths as I towed her.

Not criticizing, and certianly not blaming (HELL, you SAVED HER LIFE, FOR SURE!!!!), but it is something I would have done differently. You'll learn that in Rescue class.

And, for what it's worth, I'll dive with you anytime.
 
Bob,

Thanks for posting this and getting the facts out. Glad to hear Maggi is continuing to improve, and we hope her recovery is swift.

I know you may question yourself, but the support shown by the divers on this forum prove you did just fine. And for those of us who have dived with you and know your skills, all I can say is we would be glad to have you there if something were to happen to us.

You always have an open invitation to visit when time comes for some R & R. We're just the next stop west of Maui!

Dennis and Judy
 
bobmaggi:
...I was in a state of panic...
Bob - I need to disagree with you here. I'm sure you were anxious and worried and the adrenaline was flowing.... but I seriously doubt you paniced.

People that are paniced can't think or act in any rational way. From what you wrote in your first post, you reacted and acted appropriately and did what needed to get done..... as a result, you are uninjured and your wife is recovering!! Good job and thank you for sharing your experience.
 
I could hardly breathe myself reading your account of such harrowing recent events. I think being able to speak is courageous, those that weren’t there and hind sight can be cruel.
Any time I’ve been in a life or death I agonize if I did the right thing in the right order. This being your partner must be even more intense and I search for and wish I could find words that would bring you comfort.
To me a key facet, inherent in your very being, is that in a terrifying situation, you did not succumb to helpless panic and did everything you could. It’s the stuffing that produces heroes.
I have seen highly trained and experienced persons not able to function well, paralyzed by the horror happening before their eyes or overwhelmed with 15 things they need to be doing at once, and all, minutes ago. You remained able to act, seek solutions, work with what was available and happening at that time.
Time becomes warped in situations like this making some events occur in milliseconds while others time without end. Without stopping in disbelief you swiftly recognized a serious problem and directly moved into problem solving. Multitasking and still viewing ahead - able to remember ramifications of actions with no time to contemplate what would be the best thing to do. Clearly those actions were successful.
I wish both of you well and sincerely hope you can focus on the success and your outstanding capabilities.
Aloha nui loa,
Lisa
 
As an emergency physician, I can say WELL DONE

Please keep us appraised of her recovery
 
"The best we can determine is that she inhaled without purging the reg so aspirated lake water which started a choking/coughing fit which would lead to more water being aspirated."Bobmaggi

Great job. That must have been very scary.

I'm very unclear on what caused her to drop her reg in the first place. Please forgive my ignornace. Why would she have inhaled water thru her reg? Why did she need to purge if reg was working properly on the boat, on the surface, and on the way down? Faulty reg?

I have silent reflux which causes me to cough on occassion. I have had a short duration coughing fit UW at depth, the longest which lasted about 20 seconds, but all I did was cough thru my reg. Is this a gear failure, or did she just accindently drop reg out of her mouth? Is she able to tell you?

I can only hope I do as well as you if ever someone needs my help.
 
bobmaggi

Thank you for sharing your experience with all of us.

I think the main thing to remember here is that what ever you did worked. She's alive and recovering. I know it's easier said then done but try not to worry about what you didn't do or what you think you forgot because you can not change it now.

You can analyze the situation to try and be better next time but lets hope that there is no next time. Just don't start to feel guilty because you think forgot something you did what you did and it all worked out.

GOOD JOB!!!!
 

Back
Top Bottom