Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
donooo:Time,,, it's all about the instructor.
Time,,, do you want to learn it, or just pass it ?
If you want to learn it, the card is just the entry requriement.
don O
Realistically, this story is not about the DM's water skills. Taking the 5' vis into account, the instructor used poor judgement taking 12 students into the water. After all, the ratio is a maximum, not a minimum. As the DM, if in your judgement the dive was unsafe in those conditions, you should not have gone along with the dive.jbichsel:Imagine a newly minted DM, (60-70 dives in career) assisting an instructor and one other DM with 12 students on OW dive 1. Platform is at 28', visibility is <5', water temp 75 degrees. Three divers exhibited nervousness during pool training requiring additional pool sessions, but were able to meet agency "standards adn mastery".
This DM is watching one end of the arc of students while the instructor and other DM are assessing skills on the other end. Now the 95 lb lady one the end starts choking for some reason, and this new DM swims to her to assist. She spits out her reg, pulls off her mask and gets a death grip on her power inflator. Then, just to make things even more fun, she pulls the new DM's reg out of his mouth, yanks off his mask and starts hitting him, all the while trying to set a new breaching record.
JungleJoe:But I am not liable for training them....
jbichsel:I think that DM candidates should be required to have 150 dives minimum to begin, 250 to complete, at least 20 deep, 15 night, .....I could go on. Additionally I think that a skills assessment should be done; not just swimming and treading water, but buoyancy control, finning techniques, control of panic situations, etc.
Would I have reacted the same way with the agency required minimum "experience" as a new DM? Doubtful. True, some people would be exceptional and handled it well. Most however, I believe, would not. Due to the responsibility entrusted and placed on diving professionals, the standards need to be higher.
The worst beating I ever took was from an 84 year old 95 lb, bedridden woman.caseybird:..... , and a 95 pound women is pretty small.
This whole topic has been kicked around in the past. You might be surprised how much liability you can find in this.JungleJoe:I have introduced alot of ppl into diving, I'll let em use my oct while I'm in the pool. Just give them a taste of it and a basic understanding,....
But I am not liable for training them....