Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
Don't recall any comparisons. But there have been a couple threads discussing the SubAlert, a device which is supposed to work above and below water, but apparently doesn't work well on the surface which is the part you really care about. (The quacking noises made by the UW versions don't seem to get the attention of the person you want, while somehow annoying everyone else.)Storm:I've just started looking into signalling devices. There are a few out there. Has anyone done a comparison test between the various models?
Storm:I've never seen nor heard a Dive Alert, so please bear this in mind when I ask the followng questions.
My wife and I keep Fox 40 Whistles attached to our BCDs, and carry both a bright orange SMB (with a Pelicam minin flasher) and lime green sausage and signal mirror for surface signalling. When boating/diving in big water, I carry a set of small pencil flares in a dry canister. With all of these, just what's the cost benefit of having the Dive Alert?
Is not a good loud pealess whistle, just as good?