I have always considered the dir set up as a tech diving rig for cavers or wrecks, in which case there should be a need to dive and swim along in single file, and the octo hose should be long enough for this purpose. I have set my octopus on the left the OOA diver swims on the left. They get the full benefit of all the hose between my tank and it is not obstructed by my body. I find in practice even a OOA novice diver if necessary when swimming alongside, can follow me through a forward or backward roll. I show and tell a trainee in an of air situation, you are going to breath out, pause, and then find you cannot breath in. You are not going to have to time to get my attention and ask me politely, and wait for me to understand and donate. Logically the only reg you can instantly find and know that works is in your buddy's mouth. Just rip the reg out of my mouth. I have never seen this written in any instruction book but in the OOA situation this is what I train myself to expect. As I have an auto air we don't have to share, when the situation is calmed down I can offer the long octo for a change over. I am looking for more efficent ways for donating. I have considered a primary side valve set up on the right, OOA diver on the right, but OOA diver when lifting their left arm to dump from the dry suit or dumping from a bcd could be partly obstructed by the reg hose, and they could not hold on to me with their left hand at the same time. Donating primary side valve with reg set up on the left, OOA diver on the left fine, but in normal diving you may find the reg hose obstructing or tangling with your BCD control hose. I am not diving with highly trained professionals but novices and occasional weekend divers, so I don't expect them to have much out of air tolerence, nor do they spend enough time practising to master buddy breathing . It would be safer and easier if all our club members dived with a standard rig.