Critique my rig (and/or me!)

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

So I guess my question on the reel thing is what sort of training should accompany it? It seems simple enough, but then I read something in one post warning against hooking it directly to your BCD. OK, makes sense so a stuck reel doesn't cause an uncontrolled ascent, but that made me wonder what else I don't know about them that could be dangerous.

-Sean

like I mentioned if you can find someone, a "mentor" if you will, in your area to show you how to deploy a SMB and then watch you do a couple, that's probably the best route outside of it being a skill learned in a more advance class. And then practice...in very shallow water where the consequences of a screw up are mitigated.
 
like I mentioned if you can find someone, a "mentor" if you will, in your area to show you how to deploy a SMB and then watch you do a couple, that's probably the best route outside of it being a skill learned in a more advance class. And then practice...in very shallow water where the consequences of a screw up are mitigated.

Yeah, I have a trip to Cozumel coming up next week so I think I'll see if I can persuade one of my DM's or a fellow diver to show me the ropes, so to speak. ;)

-Sean
 


A ScubaBoard Staff Message...

Preemptive Reminder:


This thread is in the Basic Scuba Forum.

While the original post contains a few "hot button" items, please try and keep your feedback constructive and present valid reasons why you agree or disagree with a gear choices and refrain from "you're gunna die!" type responses. :)

I'm gunna die. I know. Just have to put that off as long as I can. My 2 PSI? Dive your rig, get good at using the gear that you have and make adjustments as you go.

DC
 
Yeah, I have a trip to Cozumel coming up next week so I think I'll see if I can persuade one of my DM's or a fellow diver to show me the ropes, so to speak. ;)

-Sean

Just bring a reel & a SMB & ask the DM to let you do the SMB deployment @ the end of the dive---chances are he'll let you(as a matter of fact that's how I learned long ago to do it --& the DM felt he was getting off with less work, too....but don't tell him that's part of your tip....:D)
 
People recommending deploying your safety sausage on a spool/reel are wrong and are giving dangerous advice.

In chorus...everyone together... "or you're gonna die!" :rofl3:

This is a complex skill to execute safely in a stressful situation and requires training and practice.

Let's assume that all concerned, epsecially the OP, are aware of the need to learn and practice the skill...and that the equipment advice was given in this assumption :D

The consequences of getting it wrong can be very serious. I have witnessed one uncontrolled ascent when a diver became entangled and have heard of many more.

Yes, this does happen. However, it is far more likely when divers utilise the 'safety sausage' with attached 6m of loose line, than if they properly deployed a DSMB from with a finger reel from a deeper depth. The loose line that comes with cheap 'safety sausages' is IMHO much more dangerous.

It's actually pretty hard to get entangled using a finger reel. If anything goes wrong, the reel can be released and it will continue to unspool...and can then be re-gathered by the diver. You can't do that with ratchet reels.

Deployed from a deeper depth, the DSMB requires much less initial air to be added, than if it was deployed on the safety stop. A single breath into the bag at 20m is enough to deploy the bag due to air expansion on ascent. At 6m, the diver will need to add 3-4 full breaths...whilst holding down the bag...and not getting tangled. One of the big issues that causes concern with shallow DSMB deployment is holding down a very buoyant bag, whilst coordinating the reel, line and yourself.

Deeper deployment is easier.

I recommend you seek instruction and practice practice practice before attempting this skill in a stressful situation.

It isn't that hard. ;) However, it does take some practice to get it slick and easy. To the OP; be aware that there are lots of DMs who won't have a clue about this skill. I self-taught myself to do this (using the plethora of tutorial videos on youtube) and refined it over several thousand dives. It takes me about 10 seconds to deploy, inflate and release the bag now. The skills is easy, but needs to be coordinated and precise.

Most importantly...keep the line away from your body, so that it cannot snag anything when you release the bag.

1) Prepare the reel and DSMB.
2) Hold the reel furthest from the body, at arms length.
3) Add one full breath to the DSMB.
4) Hold the DSMB away from the body, at arms length.
5) Release the DSMB.
 
Deployed from a deeper depth, the DSMB requires much less initial air to be added, than if it was deployed on the safety stop. A single breath into the bag at 20m is enough to deploy the bag due to air expansion on ascent. At 6m, the diver will need to add 3-4 full breaths...whilst holding down the bag...and not getting tangled. One of the big issues that causes concern with shallow DSMB deployment is holding down a very buoyant bag, whilst coordinating the reel, line and yourself.

Deeper deployment is easier.

Thanks Devon, I was wondering about that. If it takes more than 1 breath (i.e. in shallow water) then you also have to adjust your buoyancy presumably (or be extra quick about the remaining breaths). Makes sense. Well I'll see if I can get a chance to try it out on this next trip or at least watch someone else closely as they demonstrate.

-Sean
 
Your gear sounds fine. If you are interested in dive safety, I recommend you put your efforts into being in the water and furthering your training through the rescue course (if you have not already) rather than worry about gear.
 
You inflate with breaths from your AIRII purge.

And avoid burning your fingers.
 
I'm curious why you would want a critique of your gear choices. They are your choices, and if you're happy with them, who cares what we think? For every diver there is another opinion of the right set of gear and the right way to use it... very few will be the same. If your gear works for you, enjoy it however you like.
 
You MUST buy a DiveRite SMB and an ALPHA Reel.
 

Back
Top Bottom